	You are now reviewing and rating John McGarry, MD Orthopaedic Surgeon Male - 4 years experience Tarpon, Pa 5425 W Spring Creek Pkwy Ste 100 Plano, TX 75024	Overall Rating


1. Overall, what is your opinion of this doctor?


2. Now, tell us how this doctor rates on...
Ease in getting an appointment			Don't Know
Waiting time during a visit			Don't Know
Courtesy and professionalism of office staff			Don't Know
Accuracy in diagnosing a problem			Don't Know
Bedside manner (caring)			Don't Know
Spending enough time with me			Don't Know
Following up as needed after my visit			Don't Know
How long was your wait at the office?

Reset My Ratings

3. Leave a Review for Dr. John McGarry

Title (optional):

Comments (optional):

Author (optional):

By clicking on Next, I agree to the Terms of Use for Vitals.
For more information about this, click here.

Highlights about Dr. John McGarry

• Patients' Choice
• Completed fellowship
• 3 star medical school

• Dr. John McGarry has an overall rating of

3 stars out of 9 reviews.

What others are saying about
Dr. John McGarry

John McGarry, MD My knee surgery went well. I am back to running regulary w/out any problems. Dr. Mcgarry spent ample time with me to explain what he was doing and why. Follow up visits were fast and helpful.
John McGarry, MD Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons. He spent time with me and answered all my questions. He has an excellent bedside manner
John McGarry, MD Absolutely horrible! One of the worst experiences of my life. Dr. McGarry acts as if you're bothering him. He doesn't spend more than 5 minutes with you to discuss anything PERIOD. He's condescending if you get a chance to ask him anything as he's darting out of the room with obviously somewhere better to be. How much confidence in him does he expect his patients to have when everything he says and does implies he could care less about me, my treatment, and more important, my recovery. I would never recommend him. I got fed up and went to Plano Orthopedics. Everyone there was great. They took the time to explain things. They seemed to actually care. Nothing like McGarry. My best advise...stay away from Tarpon Orthopedics and Dr. McGarry.
John McGarry, MD McGarry performed knee scope on me. Surgery went well but I was injured in physical therapy. Now I'm left partially disabled and he says there's nothing which can be done. He doesn't spend more then 5 minutes with you, and doesn't like answering questions. He horribly mislead about recovery time. Seemed more interested in doing surgery then what was best for patient. Staff is incompetent. They screwed up getting post-op instructions and other vital information.
John McGarry, MD Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons I have visited. He has a wonderful bedside manner and explains things in detail. He even drew a diagram to explain my shoulder problem. Surgery went very well and I am on my way to full recovery.
John McGarry, MD Dr McGarry was very accurate on his diagnosis. I had a lenghty list with questions related to my torn ACL, and he spend the time to explain each one of them in detail, as well as my recovery options, including surgery.
Reviewer: C. Pinske
My knee surgery went well. I am back to running regulary w/out any problems. Dr. Mcgarry spent ample time with me to explain what he was doing and why. Follow up visits were fast and helpful.
Reviewer: 1
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons. He spent time with me and answered all my questions. He has an excellent bedside manner
Reviewer: 2
Absolutely horrible! One of the worst experiences of my life. Dr. McGarry acts as if you're bothering him. He doesn't spend more than 5 minutes with you to discuss anything PERIOD. He's condescending if you get a chance to ask him anything as he's darting out of the room with obviously somewhere better to be. How much confidence in him does he expect his patients to have when everything he says and does implies he could care less about me, my treatment, and more important, my recovery. I would never recommend him. I got fed up and went to Plano Orthopedics. Everyone there was great. They took the time to explain things. They seemed to actually care. Nothing like McGarry. My best advise...stay away from Tarpon Orthopedics and Dr. McGarry.
Reviewer: 5
McGarry performed knee scope on me. Surgery went well but I was injured in physical therapy. Now I'm left partially disabled and he says there's nothing which can be done. He doesn't spend more then 5 minutes with you, and doesn't like answering questions. He horribly mislead about recovery time. Seemed more interested in doing surgery then what was best for patient. Staff is incompetent. They screwed up getting post-op instructions and other vital information.
Reviewer: 7
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons I have visited. He has a wonderful bedside manner and explains things in detail. He even drew a diagram to explain my shoulder problem. Surgery went very well and I am on my way to full recovery.
Reviewer: 8
Dr McGarry was very accurate on his diagnosis. I had a lenghty list with questions related to my torn ACL, and he spend the time to explain each one of them in detail, as well as my recovery options, including surgery.
Reviewer: C. Pinske
My knee surgery went well. I am back to running regulary w/out any problems. Dr. Mcgarry spent ample time with me to explain what he was doing and why. Follow up visits were fast and helpful.
Reviewer: 1
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons. He spent time with me and answered all my questions. He has an excellent bedside manner
Reviewer: 2
Absolutely horrible! One of the worst experiences of my life. Dr. McGarry acts as if you're bothering him. He doesn't spend more than 5 minutes with you to discuss anything PERIOD. He's condescending if you get a chance to ask him anything as he's darting out of the room with obviously somewhere better to be. How much confidence in him does he expect his patients to have when everything he says and does implies he could care less about me, my treatment, and more important, my recovery. I would never recommend him. I got fed up and went to Plano Orthopedics. Everyone there was great. They took the time to explain things. They seemed to actually care. Nothing like McGarry. My best advise...stay away from Tarpon Orthopedics and Dr. McGarry.
Reviewer: 5
McGarry performed knee scope on me. Surgery went well but I was injured in physical therapy. Now I'm left partially disabled and he says there's nothing which can be done. He doesn't spend more then 5 minutes with you, and doesn't like answering questions. He horribly mislead about recovery time. Seemed more interested in doing surgery then what was best for patient. Staff is incompetent. They screwed up getting post-op instructions and other vital information.
Reviewer: 7
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons I have visited. He has a wonderful bedside manner and explains things in detail. He even drew a diagram to explain my shoulder problem. Surgery went very well and I am on my way to full recovery.
Reviewer: 8
Dr McGarry was very accurate on his diagnosis. I had a lenghty list with questions related to my torn ACL, and he spend the time to explain each one of them in detail, as well as my recovery options, including surgery.
Reviewer: C. Pinske
My knee surgery went well. I am back to running regulary w/out any problems. Dr. Mcgarry spent ample time with me to explain what he was doing and why. Follow up visits were fast and helpful.
Reviewer: 1
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons. He spent time with me and answered all my questions. He has an excellent bedside manner
Reviewer: 2
Absolutely horrible! One of the worst experiences of my life. Dr. McGarry acts as if you're bothering him. He doesn't spend more than 5 minutes with you to discuss anything PERIOD. He's condescending if you get a chance to ask him anything as he's darting out of the room with obviously somewhere better to be. How much confidence in him does he expect his patients to have when everything he says and does implies he could care less about me, my treatment, and more important, my recovery. I would never recommend him. I got fed up and went to Plano Orthopedics. Everyone there was great. They took the time to explain things. They seemed to actually care. Nothing like McGarry. My best advise...stay away from Tarpon Orthopedics and Dr. McGarry.
Reviewer: 5
McGarry performed knee scope on me. Surgery went well but I was injured in physical therapy. Now I'm left partially disabled and he says there's nothing which can be done. He doesn't spend more then 5 minutes with you, and doesn't like answering questions. He horribly mislead about recovery time. Seemed more interested in doing surgery then what was best for patient. Staff is incompetent. They screwed up getting post-op instructions and other vital information.
Reviewer: 7
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons I have visited. He has a wonderful bedside manner and explains things in detail. He even drew a diagram to explain my shoulder problem. Surgery went very well and I am on my way to full recovery.
Reviewer: 8
Dr McGarry was very accurate on his diagnosis. I had a lenghty list with questions related to my torn ACL, and he spend the time to explain each one of them in detail, as well as my recovery options, including surgery.
Reviewer: C. Pinske
My knee surgery went well. I am back to running regulary w/out any problems. Dr. Mcgarry spent ample time with me to explain what he was doing and why. Follow up visits were fast and helpful.
Reviewer: 1
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons. He spent time with me and answered all my questions. He has an excellent bedside manner
Reviewer: 2
Absolutely horrible! One of the worst experiences of my life. Dr. McGarry acts as if you're bothering him. He doesn't spend more than 5 minutes with you to discuss anything PERIOD. He's condescending if you get a chance to ask him anything as he's darting out of the room with obviously somewhere better to be. How much confidence in him does he expect his patients to have when everything he says and does implies he could care less about me, my treatment, and more important, my recovery. I would never recommend him. I got fed up and went to Plano Orthopedics. Everyone there was great. They took the time to explain things. They seemed to actually care. Nothing like McGarry. My best advise...stay away from Tarpon Orthopedics and Dr. McGarry.
Reviewer: 5
McGarry performed knee scope on me. Surgery went well but I was injured in physical therapy. Now I'm left partially disabled and he says there's nothing which can be done. He doesn't spend more then 5 minutes with you, and doesn't like answering questions. He horribly mislead about recovery time. Seemed more interested in doing surgery then what was best for patient. Staff is incompetent. They screwed up getting post-op instructions and other vital information.
Reviewer: 7
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons I have visited. He has a wonderful bedside manner and explains things in detail. He even drew a diagram to explain my shoulder problem. Surgery went very well and I am on my way to full recovery.
Reviewer: 8
Dr McGarry was very accurate on his diagnosis. I had a lenghty list with questions related to my torn ACL, and he spend the time to explain each one of them in detail, as well as my recovery options, including surgery.
Reviewer: C. Pinske
My knee surgery went well. I am back to running regulary w/out any problems. Dr. Mcgarry spent ample time with me to explain what he was doing and why. Follow up visits were fast and helpful.
Reviewer: 1
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons. He spent time with me and answered all my questions. He has an excellent bedside manner
Reviewer: 2
Absolutely horrible! One of the worst experiences of my life. Dr. McGarry acts as if you're bothering him. He doesn't spend more than 5 minutes with you to discuss anything PERIOD. He's condescending if you get a chance to ask him anything as he's darting out of the room with obviously somewhere better to be. How much confidence in him does he expect his patients to have when everything he says and does implies he could care less about me, my treatment, and more important, my recovery. I would never recommend him. I got fed up and went to Plano Orthopedics. Everyone there was great. They took the time to explain things. They seemed to actually care. Nothing like McGarry. My best advise...stay away from Tarpon Orthopedics and Dr. McGarry.
Reviewer: 5
McGarry performed knee scope on me. Surgery went well but I was injured in physical therapy. Now I'm left partially disabled and he says there's nothing which can be done. He doesn't spend more then 5 minutes with you, and doesn't like answering questions. He horribly mislead about recovery time. Seemed more interested in doing surgery then what was best for patient. Staff is incompetent. They screwed up getting post-op instructions and other vital information.
Reviewer: 7
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons I have visited. He has a wonderful bedside manner and explains things in detail. He even drew a diagram to explain my shoulder problem. Surgery went very well and I am on my way to full recovery.
Reviewer: 8
Dr McGarry was very accurate on his diagnosis. I had a lenghty list with questions related to my torn ACL, and he spend the time to explain each one of them in detail, as well as my recovery options, including surgery.
Reviewer: C. Pinske
My knee surgery went well. I am back to running regulary w/out any problems. Dr. Mcgarry spent ample time with me to explain what he was doing and why. Follow up visits were fast and helpful.
Reviewer: 1
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons. He spent time with me and answered all my questions. He has an excellent bedside manner
Reviewer: 2
Absolutely horrible! One of the worst experiences of my life. Dr. McGarry acts as if you're bothering him. He doesn't spend more than 5 minutes with you to discuss anything PERIOD. He's condescending if you get a chance to ask him anything as he's darting out of the room with obviously somewhere better to be. How much confidence in him does he expect his patients to have when everything he says and does implies he could care less about me, my treatment, and more important, my recovery. I would never recommend him. I got fed up and went to Plano Orthopedics. Everyone there was great. They took the time to explain things. They seemed to actually care. Nothing like McGarry. My best advise...stay away from Tarpon Orthopedics and Dr. McGarry.
Reviewer: 5
McGarry performed knee scope on me. Surgery went well but I was injured in physical therapy. Now I'm left partially disabled and he says there's nothing which can be done. He doesn't spend more then 5 minutes with you, and doesn't like answering questions. He horribly mislead about recovery time. Seemed more interested in doing surgery then what was best for patient. Staff is incompetent. They screwed up getting post-op instructions and other vital information.
Reviewer: 7
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons I have visited. He has a wonderful bedside manner and explains things in detail. He even drew a diagram to explain my shoulder problem. Surgery went very well and I am on my way to full recovery.
Reviewer: 8
Dr McGarry was very accurate on his diagnosis. I had a lenghty list with questions related to my torn ACL, and he spend the time to explain each one of them in detail, as well as my recovery options, including surgery.
Reviewer: C. Pinske
My knee surgery went well. I am back to running regulary w/out any problems. Dr. Mcgarry spent ample time with me to explain what he was doing and why. Follow up visits were fast and helpful.
Reviewer: 1
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons. He spent time with me and answered all my questions. He has an excellent bedside manner
Reviewer: 2
Absolutely horrible! One of the worst experiences of my life. Dr. McGarry acts as if you're bothering him. He doesn't spend more than 5 minutes with you to discuss anything PERIOD. He's condescending if you get a chance to ask him anything as he's darting out of the room with obviously somewhere better to be. How much confidence in him does he expect his patients to have when everything he says and does implies he could care less about me, my treatment, and more important, my recovery. I would never recommend him. I got fed up and went to Plano Orthopedics. Everyone there was great. They took the time to explain things. They seemed to actually care. Nothing like McGarry. My best advise...stay away from Tarpon Orthopedics and Dr. McGarry.
Reviewer: 5
McGarry performed knee scope on me. Surgery went well but I was injured in physical therapy. Now I'm left partially disabled and he says there's nothing which can be done. He doesn't spend more then 5 minutes with you, and doesn't like answering questions. He horribly mislead about recovery time. Seemed more interested in doing surgery then what was best for patient. Staff is incompetent. They screwed up getting post-op instructions and other vital information.
Reviewer: 7
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons I have visited. He has a wonderful bedside manner and explains things in detail. He even drew a diagram to explain my shoulder problem. Surgery went very well and I am on my way to full recovery.
Reviewer: 8
Dr McGarry was very accurate on his diagnosis. I had a lenghty list with questions related to my torn ACL, and he spend the time to explain each one of them in detail, as well as my recovery options, including surgery.
Reviewer: C. Pinske
My knee surgery went well. I am back to running regulary w/out any problems. Dr. Mcgarry spent ample time with me to explain what he was doing and why. Follow up visits were fast and helpful.
Reviewer: 1
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons. He spent time with me and answered all my questions. He has an excellent bedside manner
Reviewer: 2
Absolutely horrible! One of the worst experiences of my life. Dr. McGarry acts as if you're bothering him. He doesn't spend more than 5 minutes with you to discuss anything PERIOD. He's condescending if you get a chance to ask him anything as he's darting out of the room with obviously somewhere better to be. How much confidence in him does he expect his patients to have when everything he says and does implies he could care less about me, my treatment, and more important, my recovery. I would never recommend him. I got fed up and went to Plano Orthopedics. Everyone there was great. They took the time to explain things. They seemed to actually care. Nothing like McGarry. My best advise...stay away from Tarpon Orthopedics and Dr. McGarry.
Reviewer: 5
McGarry performed knee scope on me. Surgery went well but I was injured in physical therapy. Now I'm left partially disabled and he says there's nothing which can be done. He doesn't spend more then 5 minutes with you, and doesn't like answering questions. He horribly mislead about recovery time. Seemed more interested in doing surgery then what was best for patient. Staff is incompetent. They screwed up getting post-op instructions and other vital information.
Reviewer: 7
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons I have visited. He has a wonderful bedside manner and explains things in detail. He even drew a diagram to explain my shoulder problem. Surgery went very well and I am on my way to full recovery.
Reviewer: 8
Dr McGarry was very accurate on his diagnosis. I had a lenghty list with questions related to my torn ACL, and he spend the time to explain each one of them in detail, as well as my recovery options, including surgery.
Reviewer: C. Pinske
My knee surgery went well. I am back to running regulary w/out any problems. Dr. Mcgarry spent ample time with me to explain what he was doing and why. Follow up visits were fast and helpful.
Reviewer: 1
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons. He spent time with me and answered all my questions. He has an excellent bedside manner
Reviewer: 2
Absolutely horrible! One of the worst experiences of my life. Dr. McGarry acts as if you're bothering him. He doesn't spend more than 5 minutes with you to discuss anything PERIOD. He's condescending if you get a chance to ask him anything as he's darting out of the room with obviously somewhere better to be. How much confidence in him does he expect his patients to have when everything he says and does implies he could care less about me, my treatment, and more important, my recovery. I would never recommend him. I got fed up and went to Plano Orthopedics. Everyone there was great. They took the time to explain things. They seemed to actually care. Nothing like McGarry. My best advise...stay away from Tarpon Orthopedics and Dr. McGarry.
Reviewer: 5
McGarry performed knee scope on me. Surgery went well but I was injured in physical therapy. Now I'm left partially disabled and he says there's nothing which can be done. He doesn't spend more then 5 minutes with you, and doesn't like answering questions. He horribly mislead about recovery time. Seemed more interested in doing surgery then what was best for patient. Staff is incompetent. They screwed up getting post-op instructions and other vital information.
Reviewer: 7
Dr. McGarry was very different from most surgeons I have visited. He has a wonderful bedside manner and explains things in detail. He even drew a diagram to explain my shoulder problem. Surgery went very well and I am on my way to full recovery.
Reviewer: 8
Dr McGarry was very accurate on his diagnosis. I had a lenghty list with questions related to my torn ACL, and he spend the time to explain each one of them in detail, as well as my recovery options, including surgery.
Reviewer: C. Pinske

John McGarry, MD

1. Overall, what is your opinion of this doctor?

2. Now, tell us how this doctor rates on...

3. Leave a Review for Dr. John McGarry