Overall Review

3.4
  • 14 patient ratings
  • 3 comments

Last 12 months:

4.0 (+ 0.6)

3 Patient Reviews

  • Highly Satisfied
    43%
  • Satisfied
    14%
  • Neutral
    14%
  • Dissatisfied
    0%
  • Highly Dissatisfied
    29%
  • Wait Time 33.2 minutes
  • Easy Appointments
  • Promptness
  • Friendly Staff
  • Fair and Accurate Diagnosis
  • Bedside Manner
  • Spends Time With Patients
  • Appropriate Followup

Showing 1 - 3 reviews

1.0 of 5
July 29th, 2015
Dr Joe McCarthy did my primary 25 years ago (I'm...
Wait time
56 minutes
Easy Appointment
Promptness
Friendly Staff
Fair and Accurate Diagnosis
Spends Time with Patients
Appropriate Follow-up
Dr Joe McCarthy did my primary 25 years ago (I'm 46 yrs old now.) Was supposed to be a simple procedure of shaving down my bone b/c my only problem was a Greek hump, not severe, but it bothered me. He did shave it down (not scooped, did an ok job) BUT left me with severely uneven/asymmetric nostrils. He apologized, said that there's nothing he could do & sent me to Dr Nicholas Tabbal in NYC as the 'go to' revision guy. 14 months post-primary I consulted with Tabbal and he was shocked at my McCarthy nose. Dr Tabbal said it could be fixed to a certain extent but never will it be 'good', rather an 'improvement.' I opted not to go thru w/revision bc I didn't want an open surgery w/a scar which is what Tabbal said he would do. Now, I'm desperate to fix my nose bc gravity has taken its toll and my nose tip is deformed w/significant nostril asymmetry and bizarre deep tip bifidity. I've been depressed and haven't stopped thinking about my nose for 25 yrs. I deeply regret my primary and specifically poor choice in Dr McCarthy. He was uncaring, aloof, reminded me that rhinoplasty is elective w/no guarantees .... He ruined aspects of the last 25 years of my life.
Was this review helpful? Yes No

1.0 of 5
August 16th, 2012
Wait time
20 minutes
Easy Appointment
Promptness
Friendly Staff
Fair and Accurate Diagnosis
Spends Time with Patients
Appropriate Follow-up
Dr Mccarthy did orgnathic surgery many years ago and continue to suffer -he misdiagnosed me , did the wrong surgery creating a jaw malrelation and his surgery created a malunion-a significant fracture and destruction of the nasal floor-he knew about mobility but never told me or my prosthodontist till years later and I suffered brutally lost all maxillary teeth,created tmj and severe maloclusal problems as i was a skeletal clss 111 but he diagnosed me as class 1
Was this review helpful? Yes No

5.0 of 5
November 15th, 2011
Wonderful Dr.
Wait time
25 minutes
Easy Appointment
Promptness
Friendly Staff
Fair and Accurate Diagnosis
Spends Time with Patients
Appropriate Follow-up
Very caring doctor and very compassionate. He spent time with me and answered all my questions and my husbands questions about our daughter diagnoses. While we were very worried and wanted to make sure we were making the correct choice for our daughter. He was able to explain it to us and not treat us as stupid people. I would highly recommend this doctor.
Was this review helpful? Yes No

Nearby Doctors

Dr. Joseph Mccarthy, MD is similar to these 3 Doctors near New York, NY.

Doctor

Dr. Anna Kundel

8 years experience

5.0 of 5

Doctor

Dr. Robert Montgomery

28 years experience

4.4 of 5

Doctor

Dr. Mitchell Bernstein

26 years experience

3.8 of 5