Dr. David Lawrence Kamelhar, MD

Why would an established Dr make you take off a bra to listen to lungs! Ridiculous.

A little odd that he makes you take off all your underwear to listen to your lungs. Very uncomfortable feeling.

If you don’t mind waiting 2 hours plus he is a good MD. Caring and competent. But over books regularly. Have never waited less than 2 hours

The best pulmonary doctor in the Entire United States

Since my situation was having emergency, I needed to see a physician. While he seem to be thorough and had a strong knowledge of medicine, his personality was so abrasive and so difficult that I was on pins and needles throughout our visits. If I would ask a question, he would yell at me, then apologize for yelling. Then when I asked another question or need a comment, he would snap at me. My wife came with me on my third visit, and she was in shock at how I managed to endure his difficult personality. I look forward in the future to see another pulmonary specialist – anyone but Dr. Kammelhar.

Dr. Kamelhar is a nice and caring person, and a brilliant doctor. He spent a lot of time (which, as everybody knows, is not typical of many doctors) patiently listening to all of my complaints, asking many additional questions, analyzing my x-rays (not only the last one, but the previous ones as well!), reviewing the blood test results, and, finally, on a thorough physical examination. Then he explained to me possible reasons for my problem, the ways to treat it, and answered all my questions. To summarize, I am extremely happy that I made a call and scheduled an appointment with Dr. Kamelhar!

He's a miracle worker and the most thorough doctor I've ever known. Also a thoroughly nice man.

Brilliant doctor. Usually has a very, very long wait time. Many (most?) of his patients are older to elderly and often arrive late themselves. He NEVER turns them away. I've seen this occur many times. As many have mentioned he does not apologize for making you wait, so don't get irked by that. But he spends a lot of time with you. If he seems like he is moving on from a subject you want to talk about, all you need to so is ask for him to stay on the subject. Dr. Kamelhar is most amenable to patient needs. You just have to advocate for yourself. Personally, he is a lovely man. He went out of his way for me when he did not have to, returns calls, if not same day, within 2-3 days. I called with an important call once, and he had his partner call me back because he was unable to same day. His office, manner, and style can sometimes be frustrating, but no one is perfect. Small price to pay for his knowledge and the fact that he cares, though it might not show. He is a very caring doctor.

A person in the office said he thinks Dr. Kamelhar is probably the best pulmonologist in NYC, and I think that is likely. Dr. Kamelhar amazed me with his expansive knowledge, is thorough and careful, and takes the time he needs. He is kind and caring, which is huge. His office staff warned me that he is often very late for appointments, and even though I haven't experienced a wait yet, I consider it totally worth it.

Read some of the reviews above and I understand that you can't be everything for everyone. I had a great experience with the staff and with the Dr. The staff was polite and professional. Tom, the person that administered the breathing test, put me at ease and was very personable and efficient. When I met Dr.Kamelhar, I understood why I was informed that the wait to see the Dr. could be long, Dr. Kamelhar wants to know a lot about you, he is attentive, personable and thorough. If you are looking for a pulmonologist, Dr. Kamelhar should be your chice.

David Kamelhar is a brilliant doctor and a very caring person. He diagnosed me and saved my life. He is extremely thorough and knowledgeable. He is also very patient and never misses even a tiny detail pertaining to his patients condition.HE IS BEST OF THE BEST. His staff is also very caring and accommodating. In addition Dr.Kamelhar has one of the best respiratory lab which is one of the most valuable diagnostic tools.

He's one of the best doctors I've seen for my complicated health situation. He correctly diagnosed me for pneumonia, when another doctor thought I had asthma!The wait can be long, but worth it. Follow-up is excellent.

***** I believe Dr. Kamelhar is the best doctor I have. He never takes the easy way out and I believe he always has the best interests of his patients behind every decision he makes. At first he appears intimidating, but once you've spoken to him, and discussed your case with him, you come to realize he is a kind and caring physician who only wants and demands the best for his patients. I would highly recommend Dr. Kamelhar to everyone who needs a pulmonologist. In addition, his office staff is helpful, polite, kind and they interact with the patients beautifully.

Dr. Kamelhar is an extremely skilled and experienced doctor. He has helped me greatly with getting control over my lung issues including bronchitis, astma, breathing difficulties. He monitors the status of his patients and has top knowledge in his area. Some complain that it is too long of a waiting time in his office but it is worth it to get the best of care! I am very comfortable with his skills and feel he really cares about my overall health.

Smartest, best doctor ever. He takes his time making a diagnosis - and doesn't take the easy way out - thorough!

I have been his patient for over 20 years and he is the best diagnostician you could ever find - and a very caring person

Rude Rude Rude. Moneymill

If you can get past his manner, he's a good doctor. In spite of what others have said, I do feel he cares. Maybe his office is too busy, but I've never been turned away and have seen others walk in on short notice, then complain about the waiting time, but he makes time to see everyone. He works until late in the evening and has returned call as late as 10 pm. I don't think this shows not caring. I think his wanting to be available for all maybe gets in the way of his manner. His office staff is terrific. He's put himself out advising me on a peripherally related medical issue and I am grateful for that.

He is brusque with patients and never, ever returns phone calls. Waiting time in the office is interminable. His attention to patients and his manner have caused patients not to see a doctor when they are feeling unwell.

He is a bully who cannot deal with a patient who participates in his or her own health care. It may be that his invalidating and condescending manner is a cover-up for his inability to deal with complicated symptom pictures. He sent me away with an incorrect protocol that, thank goodness, was corrected by a more astute and knowledgeable pulmonologist.He claims he will call back with test results but does not, and it is difficult to get copies of test results from him.