The Vitals website is provided for your informational use only. Nothing contained or offered by, on or through Vitals should be construed as medical advice or relied upon for medical diagnosis or treatment. Vitals does not recommend or endorse any particular healthcare provider whose information or ratings appear on this website. We encourage you to read our full Terms of Service.

Dr. John D Mahoney Is this you?

About Dr. John D Mahoney

Dr. John D Mahoney, MD is a Doctor primarily located in Peoria, IL. He has 18 years of experience. His specialties include Orthopaedic Surgery of the Hand, Orthopaedic Surgery and Surgery of the Hand. Dr. Mahoney has received 3 awards. He speaks English.

Rating Overview

47 Ratings with 27 Comments

The overall average patient rating of Dr. John D Mahoney is Great. Dr. John D Mahoney has been rated by 47 patients. From those 47 patients 27 of those left a comment along with their rating. The overall rating for Dr. John D Mahoney is 3.9 of 5.0 stars.

Mapbox Map of Dr. John D Mahoney

Primary Address

Midwest Orthopaedic Center Sc

6000 N Allen Rd
Peoria, IL 61614
Get Directions


Dr. John D Mahoney has the following 3 specialties

  • Orthopaedic Surgery of the Hand
  • Orthopaedic Surgery
  • Surgery of the Hand

    Hand surgeons are certified surgeons who are also experts in the function and structure of your wrists, hands and forearms. This allows them to treat arthritis, carpal tunnel, trigger finger and tennis elbow, most of which tend to result from repetitive and excessive use of the corresponding joints, muscles, tendons and ligaments.
    Hand surgeons also commonly work with patients who have fractures or broken bones from any kind of accident. If you're experiencing any kind of general pain in your hand, wrist or forearm that isn’t going away, a hand surgeon is probably your best resource.

  • Expertise

    4 Expertise

  • Dupuytren's Contracture
  • Hip Osteoarthritis
  • Osteoarthritis (Hand and Wrist)
  • Knee Osteoarthritis

Board Certifications

See the board certifications this doctor has received. Board certifications provide confidence that this doctor meets the nationally recognized standards for education, knowledge and experience.


Showing 5 of 47

Don't bother

My daughter had a very complicated wrist surgery in a CHicago hospital and was told we could follow up with a local Dr so we did not have to continue making a 3 hour trip to CHicago .Dr Mahoney was super nice the first visit when everything was going smoothly and he basically did not have to do anything but get paid. After a few weeks there was no progress with physical therapy and my daughter was having a lot of pain and then he was just done !, he did not want to be bothered with her problems, no explanation for what he thought might be going on, he was rude, uncaring and his entire personality changed towards us. I thought the nurses were equally rude and no help what so ever He told us to go back to the surgeon who did the surgery which I totally agreed we needed to do but it was the way he handled it, He could not be bothered and seemed to care less.

Full Review Rating Breakdown
Lacking in people skills & A LOUSY DOCTOR

I, too, wish I had read the comments for this doctor before making an appointment. If I had I would not now be sending Midwest Orthopaedic a check. I, like many others, have arthritis. One Saturday morning I woke up to my right hand and forearm swelled to twice their normal size. I was unable to dress myself. I also must add that I have cysts on both hands near my wrists. By Monday I wasn't much better so I made an appointment for Thursday to see Dr. Mahoney. Upon paying the bill it now sounds as though I have buyer's remorse. I have no problem paying for competent medical care. I do, however, have a problem paying a doctor to comment on the guy mowing the grass outside his office window. Dr. Mahoney may well be an okay doctor when dealing with children and their mothers. As for me, it was a total waste of time and money.

Easy Appointment
Friendly Staff
Accurate Diagnosis
Bedside Manner
Spends Time with Me
Appropriate Follow-up
Full Review Rating Breakdown
Horrible Care

I injured my pinky and was told I didn't need an x-ray but he could do one that day and call me with the results or I could not have one and call back if I had continued to experience pain after two weeks. He spent two minutes in the exam room that day and I paid forty bucks. I did continue to experience pain after two weeks, so I called back as suggested and no one would order me an x ray because he didn't list what he had told me in his office note. The nurse Kathy wanted to charge me for another visit. I tried to explain to them what he had told me and was treated with very curtly. She said she would get back with me. I called the nurse Kathy a few minutes after I missed her call on Thursday and was unable to reach her so left a message for her to return my call. No problem. No one ever returned my call. After waiting for a return call for five days, I called and got an x ray order but was told I wound not get my results called to me. I believe this is a case of being treated rudely because I didn't make an appointment as the nurse had suggested, which made her have to actually ask him a question. I'm assuming she portrayed me as a irate patient, which I was not at all. Disgusted with the care and the treatment from this office. As a RN myself I never treat people this rudely. You should go here if you want to be treated like less than human.

Easy Appointment
Friendly Staff
Accurate Diagnosis
Bedside Manner
Spends Time with Me
Appropriate Follow-up
Full Review Rating Breakdown
Save yourself, go elsewhere

Dr Mahoney did not fuse my finger tip knuckle as described in consults and during my surgery to remove a severed tendon and fuse my knuckle, decided my knuckle looked( just to good to fuse ) and instead put in a pin that had to later be pulled out and eventually had to have another surgery to do what he wouldn't. I also must mention the difficulty of getting my records to a competitors office for my new surgeon. Thumbs down on this doctor and the office manager!

Wait time
35 minutes
Easy Appointment
Friendly Staff
Accurate Diagnosis
Bedside Manner
Spends Time with Me
Appropriate Follow-up
Full Review Rating Breakdown
Five Stars

Excellent physician, but my issue is with Midwest Orthopedic in general and not the surgeon as I have heard he is quite excellent. If you have a break but not a referral (like if you go through Urgent Care), one gets to wait 1 week to 10 days to get in. During that time, drink whiskey, swear, or get addicted to pain meds while you wait to get in. They need to hire more docs or find a way to treat breaks within the same week, in my opinion. Right now I'm doping up on Motrin and crying while I wait for my time in the office. I just hope my break doesn't heal crooked before I get into the office. And I have good insurance too.

Full Review Rating Breakdown
  • Awards

    3 Awards

  • Patients' Choice Award (2010)

    Patients' Choice recognition reflects the difference a particular physician has made in the lives of his/her patients. The honor is bestowed to physicians who have received near perfect scores, as voted by patients.

  • Compassionate Doctor Recognition (2010)

    Compassionate Doctor certification is granted to physicians who treat their patients with the utmost kindness. The honor is granted based on a physician's overall and bedside manner scores.

  • On-Time Doctor Award (2015, 2009, 2014)

    Vitals On-Time + Promptness Award recognizes doctors with consistent high ratings for timeliness of appointments. The honor is granted based on a physician's overall and promptness scores.

  • Education

    18 Years Experience

  • Yale University School Of Medicine

    Graduated in 2000

  • Accepted Insurance

    Dr. John D Mahoney accepts the following insurance providers.

  • BCBS Blue Card
    • BCBS Blue Card PPO
  • BCBS Illinois
  • Cigna
    • CIGNA Open Access Plus
  • Coventry Health Care
    • Coventry Health and Life IL PPO
    • Coventry HealthAmerica PPO
    • Coventry IL PPO
    • Coventry MO HMO POS
    • Coventry MO PPO
    • CoventryOne PPO Network
  • First Health
    • First Health PPO
  • Health Alliance
    • Health Alliance HMO/POS
    • Health Alliance PPO
  • HealthLink
    • HealthLink PPO
  • Humana
    • Humana Choice POS
    • Humana ChoiceCare Network PPO
    • Humana National HMO
    • Humana Preferred PPO
  • United Healthcare
    • UHC Choice Plus POS
    • UHC Navigate HMO
    • UHC Navigate POS
    • UHC Options PPO
  • View by Location

Locations & Directions

Midwest Orthopaedic Center Sc, 6000 N Allen Rd, Peoria, IL


Take a minute to learn about Dr. John D Mahoney in this video.

  • Nearby Doctors

    Dr. John D Mahoney is similar to the following 3 Doctors near Peoria, IL.