Filter Vitals Ratings
6 Ratings • 3 Comments
- 1
- 1
- 4
Quality Rating
Dissatisfied
- Easy Appointments
- Promptness
- Friendly Staff
- Accurate Diagnosis
- Bedside Manner
- Spends Time With Patients
- Appropriate Followup
- Most Recent
- Oldest
- Highest Rated
- Lowest Rated
No data
- Most Recent
- Oldest
- Highest Rated
- Lowest Rated
No data
Three Stars
Self-verified patient of Dr. John A MacPhail - Posted on April 10th, 2017
Five Stars
Self-verified patient of Dr. John A MacPhail - Posted on April 10th, 2017
MacPhail more like McFail
Self-verified patient of Dr. John A MacPhail - Posted on July 14th, 2016
I fractured my left arm when I was about 9 years old (I'm now 17) My parents took me to his practice to get my arm fixed. He said I would need a closed reduction surgery on my arm and did the job and everything healed ok and I got my cast off. About 3 week after having my cast off I was running in PE and got tripped and fell and broke the same arm again. We went back to him again and he said I'd need a closed reduction surgery again, except this time he made my arm worse after surgery. The bone was offset and I now needed to go to children's hospital and get pins and plates and all of that to fix his mistake. I still remember all of that to today because it was a horrible and scarring experience. I hope his medical license has been revoked by now.
One Star
Self-verified patient of Dr. John A MacPhail - Posted on August 1st, 2015
One Star
Self-verified patient of Dr. John A MacPhail - Posted on January 15th, 2012
Dr. McPhail treated my young daughter years ago and was TERRIBLE, he was mad she wouldn't hold still for her cast removal.He needs to have a better attitude!!!!!!
Dr. MacPhail's Surgical Skills
Self-verified patient of Dr. John A MacPhail - Posted on December 22nd, 2010
He totally screwed up a hip fracture surgery by breaking the leg, letting the patient bleed out during surgery which caused a heart attack. Do not let this doctor do surgery on you or any of your family.