- Wait Time
- Easy Appointments
- Friendly Staff
- Accurate Diagnosis
- Bedside Manner
- Spends Time With Me
- Appropriate Followup
Share Your Experience
Have you seen Dr. John P Reilly?
Very Pleasant experience
A patient who verified they visited Dr. John P Reilly - Posted on November 9th, 2017
Professional office staff & wait time was minimal. Dr. Reilly a gem! Repaired my meniscus with excellent results.
Self-verified patient of Dr. John P Reilly - Posted on April 21st, 2017
He is excellent, the only one I would trust to operate on me and he has. He also oversaw my daughters tibia fracture .. The best
Self-verified patient of Dr. John P Reilly - Posted on December 13th, 2016
I have been a patient of Dr. Reilly since 1992. He has performed several successful surgeries on me that have allowed me to continue my active style. He has a great bedside manor and instill a sense of confidence in his patients. I highly recommend him to anyone requiring orthopedic care.
The best Doctor!!!!
Self-verified patient of Dr. John P Reilly - Posted on June 28th, 2016
Outstanding Dr in Staten Island, the BEST in my opinion. Extremely knowledgable as well as compassionate, kind and sincere. The staff is fantabulous!!!! Fantastic/ fabulous rolled up into 1. Very sweet kind and caring. Perfect 10!
A review by a patient that verified they have visited Dr. John P Reilly - Posted on April 27th, 2016
My husband recently had a visit with Dr. Reilly. I found him thorough and real old time professional doctor. I would highly recommend him
One of the "Best"!
Self-verified patient of Dr. John P Reilly - Posted on March 3rd, 2015
Dr. Reilly is a caring "old fashion" doctor...his professional wisdom and caring manner make him a dying breed. I have gone to Dr. Reilly for about 15 yrs and had 2 total knee replacements, carpal tunnel and trigger finger surgery.
Self-verified patient of Dr. John P Reilly - Posted on December 30th, 2014
VERY UNPROFESSIONAL OFFICE STAFF!!!
Self-verified patient of Dr. John P Reilly - Posted on February 4th, 2014
Dr. Reilly is a great orthopedic, no question about it, his medical background and education are beyond exceptional. Unfortunately, the staff working in the front office (yes, those people you see when you just walk in and look like they really don't want to be there; you know, those that make you fill out a ton of paper work and are very indifferent to your needs as a patient) are very inefficient, unprofessional and incompetent, to say the least. There is a young receptionist (who by the way, spends more time checking and texting on her phone that actually doing her job) who request to get a lunch break every five minutes. They misplaced your insurance cards, make mistakes with your names and birthdays, they even forget to charge you their co-payment. PROS: the doctors, technicians and PA's. (well, the 60' TV is also a plus) CONS: front office staff and junior high school receptionist.
Worst staff on Staten Island!
A review by a patient that verified they have visited Dr. John P Reilly - Posted on October 8th, 2013
The doctors in this group and specifically, Dr Reilly, should be aware that they have the nastiest, most ill mannered morons answering their phones. This uneducated, HS dropout who sounded xanaxed out, refused to assist me in an emergency. No wonder her job is taking the lunch order and sliding back the glass window. So unprofessional. This is one of the reasons SI practices get zero respect and lose patients to Manhattan!
Sheridan A. Quinonez
Self-verified patient of Dr. John P Reilly - Posted on June 14th, 2011
I move back 2 SI tomorrow. I cant wait to see my Dr. Reilly, I owe him my life. His professional and amazing bedside manner of treating his patients is above & beyond great. Now that I possiblt need an operation on my hip & my carpal tunnel needs attention, there is NO ONE I would even think of going to. God bless you Dr. Reilly - see u soon
Self-verified patient of Dr. John P Reilly - Posted on November 19th, 2017
Self-verified patient of Dr. John P Reilly - Posted on October 27th, 2017
Dr. John P Reilly is similar to the following 3 Doctors near Staten Island, NY.
- Metastatic Melanoma The facts about metastatic melanoma, a serious skin cancer.
- Skin Cancer Get the facts about skin cancer, including the types and symptoms.
- Bladder Cancer Facts about Bladder Cancer, including symptoms and treatment options
- View All Care Guides Prepare for your next visit with our extensive library of Care Guides