Dr. Mahyar Eidgah, MD

Best Doctor!

Dr. Eidgah has been my primary care doc for over 10 years. He is friendly, knowledgeable and on time. His staff is excellent and very attentive.

I have been a patient of Dr. Eidgah's for over 11 years and can honestly say he is the best primary care doctor in NYC. He is caring, warm and compassionate. I'm always able to get an appointment with him and never have a long wait in the office. He is knowledgeable and has a calm demeanor. His staff is also friendly and attentive. He is simply the best!

Dr. Eidgah and his staff always make my visits comfortable, quick, easy, and painless. Dr. Eidgah is able to manage my illnesses, mental and physical in a safe place. I never hear any judgements, and always feel completely at ease discussing my most private details. He is definitely the doctor to go to. I love that he accepts my insurance. Copays are no big deal. I’ve never really waited more than 15 mins to see the doctor.

The staff are polite enough, just unbelievably difficult, forgetful, and to me, unhelpful. This isn't about one instance; I've been seeing Dr Eidgah for over a year, have been in numerous times for different things. Dr Eidgah manages my prescriptions. None of them are dangerous, habit forming, narcotic, etc, just totally basic stuff. Yet still the staff repeatedly makes it a huge hassle to refill my prescriptions. They have failed to give messages to the doctor numerous times. They have given me incorrect info on more than one occasion. Their ineptitude has caused me to go without important meds. It's unbelievably frustrating. Thankfully I have another GP who's less inept at processing prescription refills, so I have a backup. But it's a really sucky feeling to have a doctor I rely on, be a source of worries about "will I be able to get my medication without interruption." Freaking infuriating. Every single time there's been an issue, it ultimately gets resolved (like when Dr Eidgah actually gets the message and refills the scrip), but it takes multiple calls, messages, getting worried, etc.

Always a great experience been seeing Dr. Eidgah for years. He has great bedside manner and very knowledgeable. Staff is excellent and I never have a long wait.

Dr. Eidgah and his staff are the best on the planet. I love how quickly and efficiently this practice is run. Thanks making going to the doctors office just a little bit better! Dr. Eidgah’s warm demeanor is greatly appreciated.

Incredible doctor who diagnosed me correctly with something so rare, even specialists missed it. He is brilliant and a lovely person. He sees lots of people each day, but makes you feel like your health is most important. He never keeps you waiting.

Smart, efficient, non alarmist who knows what he’s doing in every way. Runs a terrific office that I recommend to the people I care about most.

Great primary care doc, very attentive and really cares about his patients. I highly recommend him!

This doctor had the nerve to call the police on me and broke every rule in the Hippa book because I asked an question. The staff is rude . But this seems to be a reoccurring theme on all his reviews . reporting this quack to my insurance carrier He does not deserve my money shameful

Dr. Eidgah and staff are caring attentive and provide excellent care! He is the best primary car doc in NYC!

Dr. Eidgah is the best of the best of the best. Kind, articulate, open minded, understanding, intelligent, clear in procedure, information, and treatment. My whole family loves him and lucky to call him our PCP for over a decade now!

Dr. Eidgah is a great doctor who truly cares about his patients. He listened to all my concerns and answered all of my questions. I was able to get all necessary testing done right in the office and got my results in couple of days with detailed explanations. I would definitely be returning to him and recommending him to all my friends.

Never returned phone calls to me or to the hospital I was admitted to.

Racist doctor that does not want to see minorities. Billing dept overcharged me by over $170.

Dr. Eidgah is an efficient primary care physician during checkups. His communication methods, however, are completely unprofessional. I received an emailed report after a check-up listing several alarming diseases in red. Upon calling his office Friday several times for more information, I was told he was too busy & would call back. Instead, I received a voicemail (from his rude secretary) on Monday saying my health was fine. Spent my weekend wondering if I needed treatment & never heard directly from him - despite him clearly saying I can call with any questions!

Caring, compassionate, smart, and friendly! I have been seeing Dr. Eidgah for years and have very high regard for him! He allows same day appointments and always returns phone calls. Highly recommended!!!

Dr. Eidgah is a great primary care doc! Highly recommend.

Dr. Eidgah is by far the best primary care doc I've seen in NYC! He is professional, friendly, compassionate and offers great advice! His staff is also competent and nice. They have a totally digital check in system (via a pad) and are totally paperless!!! Highly recommended!!!!