On Monday, September 15, 2025, at 9:30 AM we went to an appointment with Doctor Nestor Ricardo Villamizar, MD, a specialist in thoracic surgery and thoracic surgical oncology at UHealth Tower, University of Miami.
I want to write this review because my experience was the worst. My father, Enrique Manito Rodriguez, born August 20, 1945, came to the appointment after a chest X-ray in the emergency room showed a mass in his left lung that looked malignant. Two doctors reviewed the CT scan that his pulmonologist had ordered. After they looked at the images, they went to Dr. Villamizar so he could give his opinion.
When the doctor walked in, he had a very unpleasant attitude. He told my father flatly that he had lung cancer. He said that at eighty years old, using an oxygen concentrator, and sitting in a wheelchair ( which was his assumption, because my father was not disabled ) he would not operate on him, because he might die during surgery. He said he would order a brain MRI, a PET/CT… scan, and a bronchoscopy. He also said he would refer him to Doctor Elio Donna.
My husband and I were in shock at how harshly he spoke to my father. He could have shared his opinion in a caring and professional way, but he did not. My father was eighty years old. The doctor did not try to imagine how my father would feel hearing such terrible news. He never asked if I, his daughter, wanted him to know everything. I will never forget my father’s face when this man, who calls himself a doctor, told him all that without any emotional support or a kind word.
From the moment we left, my father was never the same. He sank deeply into depression. He stopped going out. He stopped smiling. Day by day he declined, because that doctor seemed to give up on him. My father had always been hopeful. If Dr. Villamizar had handled this with more kindness, maybe my father would have faced his prognosis with more strength.
Sadly, my father passed away on October 7, 2025, less than a month later.
About the bronchoscopy with biopsy by Doctor Elio Donna on September 22, 2025: when we brought my father in, we left him with the nurse, and we never saw Dr. Donna. After the procedure, they told us he was done and walked him down, but that doctor never came to speak to us about my father’s condition. He told my father the results were positive, that he had cancer in both lungs, and that he needed to see an oncologist right away. This was right after the procedure. My father was in pain, even though we were told he would be sedated.
Two days later, the nurse called me and asked if my father had symptoms such as a cough, blood in his phlegm, or chest pain. He did have those symptoms, and he also had a fever. The doctor gave him antibiotics to prevent infection, but the infection was already there and got worse after the procedure. On the fourth day of the antibiotics I told the nurse my father still had a fever. She said she would tell the doctor, but insisted he finish the medicine. The next day my father could not breathe. His oxygen level was very low because of the infection and his chronic COPD. I rushed him to the emergency room at HCA Florida Palm Lakes. From there he was taken by ambulance to HCA Aventura Hospital. He fought for his life and the staff there treated us very well, but he was never the same.
My father died, and I believe his decline was made worse by how little compassion these doctors showed him. They treated us like we were just clients, not real patients.
The Hippocratic Oath is not just words. It means doctors must always care for their patients, keep their trust, and not cause harm.
To Dr. Villamizar and Dr. Donna, I give zero stars. I hope they never feel the pain of someone who truly wants to live. Truth is important, but empathy is essential.
It hurts me deeply that such a respected place like the University of Miami Health System would have doctors who act this way. The rest of the UHealth staff was kind and professional.
I needed to s
Read More