The Vitals website is provided for your informational use only. Nothing contained or offered by, on or through Vitals should be construed as medical advice or relied upon for medical diagnosis or treatment. Vitals does not recommend or endorse any particular healthcare provider whose information or ratings appear on this website. We encourage you to read our full Terms of Service.

Dr. Sarah S Schaefer Is this you?

About Dr. Sarah S Schaefer

Dr. Sarah S Schaefer, MD is a Doctor primarily located in Livingston, NJ. She has 29 years of experience. Her specialties include Surgery and Surgical Oncology. Dr. Schaefer has received 3 awards. She speaks English.

Rating Overview

45 Ratings with 8 Comments

The overall average patient rating of Dr. Sarah S Schaefer is Great. Dr. Sarah S Schaefer has been rated by 45 patients. From those 45 patients 8 of those left a comment along with their rating. The overall rating for Dr. Sarah S Schaefer is 4.0 of 5.0 stars.

Mapbox Map of Dr. Sarah S Schaefer

Primary Address

Saint Barnabas Ambulatory Care Center

200 S Orange Ave
Livingston, NJ 07039
Get Directions


Dr. Sarah S Schaefer has the following 2 specialties

  • Surgery
  • Surgical Oncology

    Surgical oncologists play various roles in treating cancer. They can perform biopsies to determine if a tumor is cancerous or not. If it is, they’re trained to remove the tumor, tissue, and in some cases, all or part of an organ or bodily structure where the cancer has spread. In addition to removing cancer, they can perform any reconstructive surgeries that may be necessary.
    Many surgical oncologists specialize in certain types of cancer, such as liver, lung or breast. Don’t be afraid to ask them what they have the most experience treating. When looking for a doctor, it’s important to know that general surgeons are also qualified to perform many of the same surgeries. However, surgical oncologists have specific training in recognizing and treating cancer, which some patients prefer.

Board Certifications

See the board certifications this doctor has received. Board certifications provide confidence that this doctor meets the nationally recognized standards for education, knowledge and experience.


Showing 5 of 45

Very compasionate

She seemed very caring and answered all my questions . She personally phoned me when the results of my biopsy were in.

Wait time
20 minutes
Easy Appointment
Friendly Staff
Accurate Diagnosis
Bedside Manner
Spends Time with Me
Appropriate Follow-up
Full Review Rating Breakdown
Outstanding in all Aspects

Outstanding Surgeon, Extremely Professional, Empathetic, Courteous, Kind, Great Patient Manners, in addition to following up surgery. I can go on and on. I was pleased she did my surgery and touched on my life.

Wait time
10 minutes
Easy Appointment
Friendly Staff
Accurate Diagnosis
Bedside Manner
Spends Time with Me
Appropriate Follow-up
Full Review Rating Breakdown
She truly cares about her patients

She is fabulous !!! She is reassuring and calm explaining the situation. Her radiologist who does the biopsy, is outstanding. Dr Mehta. comforting. caring. explains everything. no rush. Wonderful during a scary time in your life.

Wait time
30 minutes
Easy Appointment
Friendly Staff
Accurate Diagnosis
Bedside Manner
Spends Time with Me
Appropriate Follow-up
Full Review Rating Breakdown
One Star

I was originally diagnosed with Stage 2 Breast Cancer - according to Dr. Schaefer the most common type. Easy fix - double mastectomy with treatment and reconstructive surgery. I asked her if she would be sending me for a PET or any other type of scans to see if the cancer was just in the breast. The answer I received is that it wasn't necessary and the insurance would probably not pay for it. This was the answer I received even before the insurance company was contacted, which by the way if you have BCBS you don't need pre-authorization for any testing. I agreed thinking she is the doctor and she knows best. Dr. Schaefer then scheduled me for surgery. About 2 weeks later I started to experience pain in my lower back, I called Dr. Schaefer's office and that is when they sent me for a full body bone scan and a CAT scan of my Abdomen and Pelvis. The following Monday I received a PHONE CALL from Dr. Schaefer to tell me that she has cancelled my surgery. When I asked why she said because you now have Stage 4 Breast Cancer - the cancer had spread to my bones, lungs, and lymph nodes. She called me with this news - never asked me where I was - if I was driving, at the store - nothing. Then hung up like I was nobody. I've never heard from her again. My advice stay far away from this Doctor - she is not only unprofessional, but a heartless person.

Friendly Staff
Full Review Rating Breakdown
Five Stars

Dr. Schaefer is one of the most caring, compassionate Drs. I have ever gone to. When I heard that I had breast cancer, my whole world was turned upside down. Dr. Schaefer spent an enormous amount of time with my husband and me, thoroughly explaining every step of the way and answering each and every question we had with the outmost of respect. Dr. Schaefer goes above and beyond what most Top Drs. do. She thinks nothing of calling her patients at night to give them good results from their lab work or test results. One night I received a call from Dr. Schaefer at my house and she prefaced the conversation by saying, "I know I'm seeing you tomorrow morning at 8:30 but I didn't want you to have to wait any longer than you needed to for your test results!" I felt 100% confident with Dr. Schaefer from the first day and now 5 months later. Dr. Schaefer is known in the field for having great margins and I am so grateful that I found her. During my 6 weeks of radiation with Dr. Grann (another fabulous Dr!), I met lots of patients who had their surgery at Sloan Kettering and they were so unhappy with the lack of time their Drs. spent with them. They all said that they felt it was run like a factory. One Dr. told her patient "I'm not here to hold your hand!" WOW! Thank you Dr. Schaefer for your expertise

Easy Appointment
Friendly Staff
Accurate Diagnosis
Bedside Manner
Spends Time with Me
Appropriate Follow-up
Full Review Rating Breakdown
  • Awards

    3 Awards

  • Top 10 Doctor - City (2014)

    Top 10 Doctors are chosen by the millions of patients who visit Vitals each year to find a new doctor and share their experiences by providing ratings and reviews. In order to differentiate highly-regarded doctors from the rest for patients in search of quality care, Vitals awards Top 10 Doctor honors to those physicians within a certain specialty and geographic area who are consistently given top ratings by their patients.

  • Compassionate Doctor Recognition (2015, 2011, 2016)

    Compassionate Doctor certification is granted to physicians who treat their patients with the utmost kindness. The honor is granted based on a physician's overall and bedside manner scores.

  • Patients' Choice Award (2013, 2014, 2011)

    Patients' Choice recognition reflects the difference a particular physician has made in the lives of his/her patients. The honor is bestowed to physicians who have received near perfect scores, as voted by patients.

  • Education

    29 Years Experience

  • New York University School Of Medicine

    Graduated in 1989

  • New York University


  • Accepted Insurance

    Dr. Sarah S Schaefer accepts the following insurance providers.

  • Aetna
    • Aetna Choice POS II
    • Aetna Choice POS Open Access
    • Aetna HMO
    • Aetna Managed Choice POS Open Access
    • Aetna Signature Administrators PPO
  • BCBS Blue Card
    • BCBS Blue Card PPO
  • Cigna
    • CIGNA Open Access Plus
  • First Health
    • First Health PPO
  • Horizon BCBS
    • Horizon BCBS OMNIA - TIER1
    • Horizon Direct Access
    • Horizon HMO
    • Horizon OMNIA
    • Horizon POS
    • Horizon PPO
  • Humana
    • Humana Choice POS
    • Humana ChoiceCare Network PPO
  • Oxford Health
    • Oxford Freedom
    • Oxford Health Garden State
    • Oxford Liberty
    • Oxford Metro
  • United Healthcare
    • UHC Choice Plus POS
    • UHC Navigate HMO
    • UHC Navigate POS
    • UHC Options PPO
  • View by Locationttcqeayetrwczwezdueawsrsbdyr

Locations & Directions

Saint Barnabas Ambulatory Care Center, 200 S Orange Ave, Livingston, NJ
  • Nearby Doctors

    Dr. Sarah S Schaefer is similar to the following 0 Doctors near Livingston, NJ.