Amber A. Guth, MD

Not truthful with her patients

She operated one mynbreasts referred me the Nolan Karp I had a watermelon in one breast and a lemon in the other . She would not acknowledge she gave me a bad referral . She would not acknowledge anything was wrong . She lets you wait in the exam rooms hours when she does not want to have you confront her . She is nasty to her help . She is prejudice to her staff . She is selfish and incompetent

I am so lucky I was referred to Dr. Guth. I was able to get an appointment quickly, schedule surgery quickly and all went well. She is a caring, loving, kind and awesome doctor. She immediately put me at ease; taking the time to explain everything clearly and precisely. I am forever grateful to her and her staff and the rest of her team. I am in excellent hands! Thank you so much!

Cannot really review this doctor because I have not gotten to see her but can review the process of attempting to see her. Was referred to a breast surgeon a week and a half ago, had heard good things about Dr. Guth from a family member who had a similar experience and saw this doctor. Called, was told to send over reports for the doctor review before they would make an appointment. Called the following day to confirm records had been received, was told they were and that the doctor or assistant would get back to me. Almost a week later- after hearing nothing on a Friday morning- I called again to get an update and was extremely displeased when they told they cannot locate the records. They told me they would continue to look and call me back to ensure that the doctor saw them immediately on Tuesday, the next day she was in. Guess what- shockingly no return call from this office!! My primary care doctor is NYU Langone and has assured me that all NYU Langone doctors can see the… records in the system but this doctors office still needed them faxed so they could lose them and never call me back. Wish I could tell you about the doctor but sadly the staff that works in the office made my experience so bad that I doubt I will be seeing this doctor.

I am so thankful to have found Dr. Guth. She has the experience and is an expert in treating breast cancer. The whole NYU team is the best!

Dr. Guth is treating my mom who has just been recently diagnosed with breast cancer. She eased our minds with her knowledge, kindness, incredible bedside manor and her expertise! MY dad, brother and myself accompanied mom on her first visit to Dr. Guth and we couldn't be happier that we decided to put mom in her hands. Prior to the visit we had so many questions and concerns, however by the time the visit was complete we had all our confidence in Dr. Guth that mom was is the best hands to undergo her surgery! There are still Dr's with amazing bedside manor after all!

Beyond excellent bedside manner which is rare for a doctor. Very patient and caring. Had no pain after surgery.

Dr. Guth is exceptional in every way-knowledgeable, patient, a good listener, and clear and insightful. Her wisdom and experience are invaluable.

Despite the fact that Dr. Guth has a wonderful bedside manner and appears to care about her patients' wellbeing. However, there have been too many times where I have waited one hour or more for a 15 minute visit.

Dr. Guth is a phenomenal surgeon. Dr. Guth has the whole package as a physician, expertise, kindness, compassionate and has an excellent staff. When you speak to her you feel that she genuinely cares about you as a person which she definitely does. Trust me, I should know with a double mastectomy. She was also so nice to my elderly mom who was so worried. I highly recommend Dr. Guth and NYU Langone. Just a beautiful person.