Dr. Colleen B. Tomcik, MD | Rochester, NY | Neurologist

.about .noScriptHide .nojs-show,.truncated [data-rem],blockquote .truncated-text{ display: initial !important}.no-js-hide,.ellipsis { display: none; }.truncated:after {content: '' !important}

Dr. Colleen Tomcik is a neurologist who specializes in treating disorders of the brain and nervous system. She earned her medical degree from Indiana University School of Medicine and completed her residency at Indiana University Hospital. With 23 years of experience in neurology, Dr. Tomcik has developed extensive expertise in her field. She speaks English with her patients.

Dr. Tomcik practices at Highland Hospital and STRONG URMC in Rochester, New York. She focuses on caring for patients with epilepsy and various types of seizures, including focal seizures. Her diagnostic approach includes blood tests and chemistry panels to help evaluate neurological conditions. Patients have given Dr. Tomcik an average rating of 4.6 on Vitals, reflecting their confidence in her care.

Overview based on verified provider data

4.6

30 Ratings
23 years of experience
speaks English
Indiana University Hospital
8 written reviews
1 specialty
10 areas of expertise
2 hospital affiliations
4 office locations
Female

Gave an accurate diagnosis
Had a good bedside manner
Spent time with me

Based on patient feedback. Read the reviews

Dr. Tomcik's Ratings and Reviews

4.6

30 Ratings with 8 written Reviews

Average Wait Time 5 Minutes

How was your appointment with
Dr. Tomcik?

Patients’ Perspective

Gave an accurate diagnosis: (10) Did WellNeeds Improvement (0)
Had a good bedside manner: (10) Did WellNeeds Improvement (0)
Spent time with me: (10) Did WellNeeds Improvement (0)
Provided follow-up after the visit: (6) Did WellNeeds Improvement (0)
Flexible scheduling: (9) Did WellNeeds Improvement (0)
Saw me in a timely manner: No Ratings
Staff was courteous: No Ratings

30 ratings & reviews

Sort:

Showing 1 to 8 of 8 reviews

.rating-and-reviews .noScriptHide .nojs-show,.truncated [data-rem],blockquote .truncated-text{ display: initial !important}.no-js-hide,.ellipsis { display: none; }.truncated:after {content: '' !important}

I’ve been a patient now for a few years for concussion and aneurysm issues. She is brilliant, caring and compassionate. She is fun, too! Great sense of humor! Laughter is the best medicine! Always happy and up-beat! She is thorough with your medical history, doesn’t miss a beat. SHE LISTENS TO YOU! She’s given me clear advice and excellent follow-up. I wish every doctor had her qualities!!!

August 27th, 2019

.rating-and-reviews .noScriptHide .nojs-show,.truncated [data-rem],blockquote .truncated-text{ display: initial !important}.no-js-hide,.ellipsis { display: none; }.truncated:after {content: '' !important}

I saw Dr. Tomcik in Highland Hospital. She was so impressive with already knowing my chart and making suggestions as what to do with my pain. I highly recommend her and her abilities to diagnosis.

Did Well

Gave an accurate diagnosis
Had a good bedside manner
Spent time with me
Provided follow-up after the visit

Needs Improvement

February 27th, 2019

.rating-and-reviews .noScriptHide .nojs-show,.truncated [data-rem],blockquote .truncated-text{ display: initial !important}.no-js-hide,.ellipsis { display: none; }.truncated:after {content: '' !important}

Dr. Coleen Tomcik is outstanding in her compassion and treatment. She gives BETTER THAN EXCELLENT care!

Did Well

Gave an accurate diagnosis
Had a good bedside manner
Spent time with me
Provided follow-up after the visit
Flexible scheduling

Needs Improvement

August 31st, 2016

.rating-and-reviews .noScriptHide .nojs-show,.truncated [data-rem],blockquote .truncated-text{ display: initial !important}.no-js-hide,.ellipsis { display: none; }.truncated:after {content: '' !important}

The best neurologist ever!

Did Well

Gave an accurate diagnosis
Had a good bedside manner
Spent time with me
Provided follow-up after the visit
Flexible scheduling

Needs Improvement

May 11th, 2016

.rating-and-reviews .noScriptHide .nojs-show,.truncated [data-rem],blockquote .truncated-text{ display: initial !important}.no-js-hide,.ellipsis { display: none; }.truncated:after {content: '' !important}

Dr. Tomcik was very attentive and helpful in determining what to do with my health issues. It is difficult at times to call in and leave a message with your doctor, you really can't get anyone to answer the phone it always seems you have to leave a message and you may not have someone get back to you in 24hrs.

Did Well

Gave an accurate diagnosis
Had a good bedside manner
Spent time with me
Flexible scheduling

Needs Improvement

March 27th, 2015

.rating-and-reviews .noScriptHide .nojs-show,.truncated [data-rem],blockquote .truncated-text{ display: initial !important}.no-js-hide,.ellipsis { display: none; }.truncated:after {content: '' !important}

Dr. Tomcik had done a thorough review of my lengthy chart before coming into the room, and so we didn't have to spend half my first appointment with a review of my case history. Instead, she asked questions about current symptoms or clarified parts of my case history that were unclear to her. Then she asked me questions which none of the several neurologists I've seen have asked. All of this led to a diagnosis of my condition that has been a mystery for more than 4 years. She knows her stuff, stays current on research, and has a pleasant manner. Highly recommend her.

Did Well

Gave an accurate diagnosis
Had a good bedside manner
Spent time with me
Provided follow-up after the visit
Flexible scheduling

Needs Improvement

January 10th, 2014

.rating-and-reviews .noScriptHide .nojs-show,.truncated [data-rem],blockquote .truncated-text{ display: initial !important}.no-js-hide,.ellipsis { display: none; }.truncated:after {content: '' !important}

I can tell you without any hesitation that if you need a neurologist I would highly recommand Dr. Tomcik, she take as much time with you that she needs to make sure she gets a sense of what is going on and does a wonderful job of diagnosing your problem for you and she actually cares for you.

Did Well

Gave an accurate diagnosis
Had a good bedside manner
Spent time with me
Flexible scheduling

Needs Improvement

February 9th, 2009

.rating-and-reviews .noScriptHide .nojs-show,.truncated [data-rem],blockquote .truncated-text{ display: initial !important}.no-js-hide,.ellipsis { display: none; }.truncated:after {content: '' !important}

Dr. Tomcik listens carefully to patients and takes their symptoms seriously.

Did Well

Gave an accurate diagnosis
Had a good bedside manner
Spent time with me
Flexible scheduling

Needs Improvement

February 6th, 2009

University Of Rochester Medical Center Department Of Neurology

919 Westfall Rd Bldg CRochester, NY 14618

Tel: (585) 275-1200

Mon8:00 am - 4:30 pm

Tue8:00 am - 4:30 pm

Wed8:00 am - 4:30 pm

Thu8:00 am - 4:30 pm

Fri8:00 am - 4:30 pm

SatClosed

SunClosed

Highland Hospital

1000 South AveRochester, NY 14620

Tel: (585) 473-2200

Strong Memorial Hospital

601 Elmwood AveRochester, NY 14642

Tel: (585) 275-2100

Strong Memorial Hospital

601 Elmwood Ave Fl 5Rochester, NY 14642


Dr. Colleen Bevevino Tomcik, MD	Dr. Roshni Karnani, MD	Dr. Cinthi Pillai, MD	Dr. Huma Sheikh, MD
Neurology	Neurology	Neurology	Neurology
	Accepts New Patients	Accepts New Patients	Accepts New Patients
4.6 (30 Ratings)	4.2 (68 Ratings)	0 (0 Ratings)	5 (6 Ratings)
23 Years of Experience	21 Years of Experience	20 Years of Experience	19 Years of Experience
No Virtual Visit Option	Virtual Visit Available	Virtual Visit Available	Virtual Visit Available
Speaks English	Speaks English, Spanish, Portuguese, Hindi, Urdu, Gujarati	Speaks English	Speaks English, Urdu
Rochester , NY	New York , NY	New York , NY	New York , NY
Med School: Indiana University School Of Medicine	Med School: St Georges University School Of Medicine	Med School: Newcastle University UK	Med School: Rutgers New Jersey Medical School
Current Profile	View Profile	View Profile	View Profile

Search for your insurance and plan

Be sure to verify insurance information directly with your doctor's office, as it may undergo frequent changes.

Neurology

Alzheimer's Disease
Electromyography
Epilepsy
Headache
Migraine Disorder
Migraine Disorders
Multiple Sclerosis (MS)
Nerve Conduction Studies
Primary Headache Disorders
Stroke

Dr. Colleen Bevevino Tomcik holds an expired medical license in the state of New York.

Medical License

Medical Doctor with an expired medical license in the state of New York that expired in 2026.

Education & Training

Residency

Completed their residency at Indiana University Hospital.

Medical School

Graduated from Indiana University School Of Medicine in 2003.

NPI Number

Dr. Tomcik's NPI number is 1295949964.

Jessica Rose Ryan
Nurse Practitioner
| Rochester, NY
(0)
Dayna Basic
Nurse Practitioner
| Rochester, NY
(0)
Garrett Michael Coles
Critical Care Medicine
12 Years Exp | Rochester, NY
(0)
Anna Gershteyn
Audiology
4 Years Exp | Melville, NY
(0)
Ashlea Christa Harr
Nurse Practitioner
| Rochester, NY
(0)
Dr. Karlo John Lizarraga Mendoza, MD
Neurology
18 Years Exp | Rochester, NY
(0)
Dr. Gary Jay Myers, MD
Pediatrics
63 Years Exp | Rochester, NY
(0)
Heather Marie Pero
Nurse Practitioner
| Rochester, NY
(0)
Dr. Alexander Henry Gerhardstein
Neurology
3 Years Exp | Rochester, NY
(0)
Dr. Samantha Nicole Mussorfiti
Neurology
2 Years Exp | Rochester, NY
(0)

Does Dr. Colleen Tomcik accept virtual/telehealth appointments?: Dr. Colleen Tomcik has not indicated that they accept virtual/teleheatlh appointments. Contact their office through their Vitals profile to check for availability.
Which hospitals is Dr. Colleen Tomcik affiliated with?: Dr. Colleen Tomcik is affiliated with Highland Hospital and STRONG URMC.
What languages does Dr. Colleen Tomcik speak?: Dr. Colleen Tomcik speaks English.
Where is Dr. Colleen Tomcik's office located?: Dr. Colleen Tomcik's office is located at 919 Westfall Rd Bldg C, Rochester, NY, 14618.
Does Dr. Colleen Tomcik accept my insurance?: You can see the insurance plans that Dr. Colleen Tomcik accepts on their Vitals profile.

Our provider data is gathered directly from physicians and publicly available databases. Providers who verify their profiles gain the ability to update information, offering additional details about their specialties,education, treated conditions, performed procedures, and accepted insurances.

Reviews on Vitals are submitted by users only. Recognizing the valuable insights these reviews offer into a doctor's reputation, we maintain internal policies and protocols to ensure the quality and accuracy of all reviews. Importantly, providers cannot delete or alter reviews independently. Reviews can only be deleted or changed following an internal assessment by our customer service team.

Your feedback is highly valued and we encourage you to contact our support team should you encounter any issues.

Copyright © 2026 Vitals Consumer Services, LLC. US Patent No. 8, 694, 441. All Rights Reserved.
As more fully set forth in this website's terms of use . (1) nothing contained on or offered by or through this website should be construed as medical advice and should not be relied upon for medical diagnosis or treatment. Vitals Consumer Services, LLC ("Vitals"). the provider of this website, does not recommend or endorse any particular healthcare provider whose information or ratings appear on this website; and (2) Vitals has granted you a limited license to access and use this website for your own noncommercial use. You are not permitted to copy, reproduce, distribute, transmit, mirror, frame, scrape, extract, wrap, create derivative works of, reverse engineer, decompile or disassemble any part or aspect of this website.