Dr. Gina Greco-Tartaglia, MD

we will be leaving this practice very soon. They are now starting a pay to play scheme where you must pay $2,000 up front as a membership fee to see Dr Tartaglia or you will be relegated to the PA for your care...meanwhile they are still billing your insurance.!! I joined the practice because of Dr Tartaglias's abilities to take care of me not a PA...I am sure many patients will be looking else where.

Not a patient since they let me go as a patient many years ago for questioning their billing and they so kindly just billed my insurance for a pelvic exam for someone else.

It’s really concerning to see Trump paraphernalia displayed so prominently in the workplace of a healthcare provider during a pandemic. The fact is that Trump belittled the pandemic, costing many Americans their lives. Do the healthcare workers in this office not care? Do they believe the pandemic is a hoax? Do they not care that their counterparts in infectious disease and emergency medicine have been working nonstop for more than a year, some even being driven to suicide as a result? Outrageous - this office is a disappointment to the medical profession

I’m way past due in finding a new doctor. I’ve mostly seen Dr. T’s PAs during my time as a patient. The one I really liked is no longer with the practice. The care hasn’t been bad. Negatives: The office staff tend to be robotic at best, and rude at their worst. They tend to overdo the testing, in my opinion. My last visit left me with a lab bill of nearly $1000. I advise anyone to really ask questions about what tests are being ordered. The pro-Trump paraphernalia is off-putting. In 2016, I noticed a banner on the office wall, within clear view of the waiting room. Gross, but whatever. It wasn’t really in my face. In 2020, that changed. Trump stickers all over the office window where I have to sign in and pay. Clearly the doctor has the right to vote as she sees fit. The thing is, I no longer felt welcome there. Political flag waving does not belong in this environment. We aren’t talking about sports teams. I wonder now, does the doctor believe Dr. Fauci or Trump (and other… anti-maskers) regarding COVID-19? It is a concern. In any case, I wish the doctor well. True family practices are few and far between. It is a pity that this doctor chose politics over patients.

She has been the worst PCP I have ever seen!!! The women that work in the office are nothing but rude, unhelpful & some days, down right nasty. You're insurance will also be billed to death, this is the only Dr that will bill you for calling in a prescription. I recently lost my job due to Covid & lost my insurance, I called to explain to the office and asked if they would please call in my prescription. They REFUSED my necessary medication because I couldn't pay for an office visit and All the tests they do every single month, which is absolutely NOT necessary (I asked another Dr to confirm) Do yourself a favor a find another Dr!!!

20 years and and a letter no longer will be my Primary. My advice is get a Primary that works with a Group.

When looking for a new Doc, I asked for recommendations from friends and neighbors in Peekskill. Dr Tartaglia was the overwhelming favorite.The people I spoke to were very passionate about not only her, but the entire team. After two years, I can say their assessments were 100% correct. Dr Taraglia sets the bar high in caring, listening, and follow up. I always feel better after leaving her office. She has taken a leadership role in benchmark bedside manor along with expert care. Many Doctors and medical staff I have preciously seen can learn much from Dt Taraglia. This family practice offers a most valuable quality missing from big corporate medical facilities.. personalized care from people who genuinely care about their patients. My highest recommendation.

Dr. Gina loves all of her patients and it shows in everything she does. She made visits to my home when my husband was dying. Who does that anymore? I wouldn’t go anywhere else. I literally trust this woman with my life.

Anyone who proudly displays a Trump- MAGA banner in their place of business will no longer get my business. Whatever your political views are, keep them out of a patient care area. Really? In this political climate? So unprofessional! I also wonder about the high rate of staff turnover and questionable billing practices. Time for me to move on.

I have been very disappointed in this practice. First off, there is a huge pro-Trump banner right when you walk in. Aside from the fact that Trump is a reprehensible human being, I should not be accosted with anyone's political viewpoints when I walk in to my doctor's office, regardless of political affiliation. Completely inappropriate. Most importantly, they are terrible about getting back to you with test results. I always have to call and hound them. One time it was extremely urgent, as I was pregnant and there was some concern about Lyme Disease and I still had to call multiple times to get my results. Also, the doctor actual googles her recommendations to see if they are appropriate. She actually showed this to me! I can google things myself, I would like my doctor to have a lot more medical knowledge.