List Your Practice

27 Dentists Found in Shelter Island, NY

We found 27 Dentists available in Shelter Island, NY with an average 4 stars across 48 reviews. Find the best one for your needs by years of experience, distance, reviews on Vitals, and more through the filters provided below. Currently, 5 Dentists listed are accepting new patients.

Filter Dentists Results

Featured Results

Dr Lola Colbert, DDS

Dentistry
3.7
3 ratings
Flexible scheduling
23 years exp
Accepting New Patients
Virtual Visit available
Midvale, UT
"I've been a patient of Dr. Colbert since 2004." View Profile
Book Online

Dr Harvey Lester, DMD

Dentistry
0 ratings
57 years exp
Accepting New Patients
Virtual Visit available
Glastonbury, CT
Dr. Lester is a Graduate of the University of Pennsylvania School of Dental Medicine and served for two years as a Captain in the US Army Dental Corps in Alaska. View Profile
Book Online

Dr Jerry Strauss, DMD

Dentistry
4.5
2 ratings
46 years exp
Accepting New Patients
Virtual Visit available
Montgomery, AL
Dr. Jerry Strauss, DMD is a Dentistry Practitioner in Fairfield, NJ. He graduated from Boston University Henry M. View Profile
Book Online

All Results

Dr Lola Colbert, DDS

Dentistry
3.7
3 ratings
Flexible scheduling
23 years exp
Accepting New Patients
Virtual Visit available
Midvale, UT
"I've been a patient of Dr. Colbert since 2004. Besides my pediatric dentist, Dr. Colbert is the only dentist I have ever had and I will continue using her. " View Profile
Book Online

Dr Jerry Strauss, DMD

Dentistry
4.5
2 ratings
46 years exp
Accepting New Patients
Virtual Visit available
Montgomery, AL
Dr. Jerry Strauss, DMD is a Dentistry Practitioner in Fairfield, NJ. He graduated from Boston University Henry M. View Profile
Book Online

Dr Harvey Lester, DMD

Dentistry
0 ratings
57 years exp
Accepting New Patients
Virtual Visit available
Glastonbury, CT
Dr. Lester is a Graduate of the University of Pennsylvania School of Dental Medicine and served for two years as a Captain in the US Army Dental Corps in Alaska. View Profile
Book Online

Dr. Daniel Thomas Moran, DDS

Dentistry
5
1 rating
Shelter Island, NY0.2 mi
Dr. Daniel Thomas Moran, DDS is a health care provider primarily located in Shelter Island, NY, with other offices in Shelter Island, NY and WEBSTER, NH. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Robert David Blank, DDS

Dentistry
0 ratings
SHELTER ISLAND, NY0.3 mi
Dr. Robert David Blank, DDS is a health care provider primarily located in SHELTER ISLAND, NY. His specialties include Dentistry, Periodontics. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Terry L Jobe

Dentistry
5
5 ratings
Sag Harbor, NY5.5 mi
"Dr. Jobe was professional and beyond efficient. He made a very unpleasant situation simply disappear. I highly reccomend his services." View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Edward S Kondak, DDS

Dentistry
4
7 ratings
Greenport, NY2.7 mi
Dr. Edward S Kondak, DDS is a health care provider primarily located in Greenport, NY. His specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Michael Joseph Edwards, DDS

Dentistry
3.6
5 ratings
28 years exp
Accepting New Patients
Wainscott, NY9.5 mi
Dr. Michael Joseph Edwards, DDS is a health care provider primarily located in Wainscott, NY. He has 28 years of experience. His specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Perry L Silver, DDS

Dentistry
4.7
11 ratings
44 years exp
East Hampton, NY7.8 mi
"Dr. Silver is an expert in the field of dentistry. He is highly knowledgeable, professional, and has a great sense of humor that makes a visit less painful. Submitted by: Anna" View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Rebecca Lynn Sieger, DDS

Dentistry
5
1 rating
Wainscott, NY9.5 mi
"Dr. Sieger calms and relaxes before performing what is a task that is not easy." View Profile
View Profile

Dr. James Thomas Dubovick, DDS

Dentistry
4.5
2 ratings
Southold, NY4.5 mi
Dr. James Thomas Dubovick, DDS is a health care provider primarily located in Southold, NY, with another office in Southold, NY. His specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. John F French, DDS

Dentistry
4
2 ratings
47 years exp
Sag Harbor, NY5.5 mi
Dr. John F French, DDS is a health care provider primarily located in Sag Harbor, NY. He has 47 years of experience. His specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Jeffrey Scott Pierce, DDS

Orthodontics
5
1 rating
43 years exp
Southold, NY4.8 mi
"What a wonderful orthodontist. Can't say enough about Dr. Pierce. My kids teeth look great!" View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Edward S Kondak

Dentistry
0 ratings
Greenport, NY2.7 mi
Dr. Edward S Kondak is a health care provider primarily located in Greenport, NY. Their specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. David Frank Pascoe, DDS

Prosthodontics
2.5
2 ratings
52 years exp
Southold, NY5.1 mi
Dr. David Frank Pascoe, DDS is a health care provider primarily located in Southold, NY. He has 52 years of experience. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Beth T Rosner

Dentistry
4.5
4 ratings
Water Mill, NY9.8 mi
Dr. Beth T Rosner is a health care provider primarily located in Water Mill, NY. Her specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Laurence Stephen Simpson

Dentistry
0 ratings
Southold, NY3.6 mi
Dr. Laurence Stephen Simpson is a health care provider primarily located in Southold, NY, with other offices in New York, NY and New York, NY(and 2 other locations). View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Richard Robert Prieto, DDS

Dentistry
4.5
2 ratings
Cutchogue, NY8.7 mi
Dr. Richard Robert Prieto, DDS is a health care provider primarily located in Cutchogue, NY. His specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Robert T Kroepel

Dentistry
0 ratings
Southold, NY4.7 mi
Dr. Robert T Kroepel is a health care provider primarily located in Southold, NY. His specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Vincent M Claps

Dentistry
0 ratings
51 years exp
Southold, NY5.0 mi
Dr. Vincent M Claps is a health care provider primarily located in Southold, NY. He has 51 years of experience. His specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Alfred M Ciletti

Dentistry
0 ratings
47 years exp
Southold, NY5.0 mi
Dr. Alfred M Ciletti is a health care provider primarily located in Southold, NY. He has 47 years of experience. His specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Glenn W Heinze

Dentistry
0 ratings
SAG HARBOR, NY5.2 mi
Dr. Glenn W Heinze is a health care provider primarily located in SAG HARBOR, NY. His specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. William Edward Evans, DDS

Dentistry
0 ratings
Cutchogue, NY9.1 mi
Dr. William Edward Evans, DDS is a health care provider primarily located in Cutchogue, NY, with another office in Cutchogue, NY. His specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Advait Shah

Dentistry
0 ratings
East Hampton, NY9.4 mi
Dr. Advait Shah is a health care provider primarily located in East Hampton, NY. Their specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Pember Bates Edwards, DDS

Dentistry
0 ratings
Wainscott, NY9.5 mi
Dr. Pember Bates Edwards, DDS is a health care provider primarily located in Wainscott, NY. Her specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Kathryn Demetra Mirras, DDS

Dentistry
0 ratings
Accepting New Patients
Wainscott, NY9.5 mi
Dr. Kathryn Demetra Mirras, DDS is a health care provider primarily located in Wainscott, NY. Her specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dr. Kristen Mcmahon

Dentistry
0 ratings
Water Mill, NY9.8 mi
Dr. Kristen Mcmahon is a health care provider primarily located in Water Mill, NY. Her specialties include Dentistry. View Profile
View Profile

Dentists nearby

What is a Dentist and How Can They Help You?

A general dentist provides comprehensive oral healthcare, addressing dental diseases, preventive care, and restorative needs. Dentists focus on maintaining oral health while recognizing its impact on systemic wellbeing.

Dentists complete a four-year dental program (DDS or DMD) following undergraduate studies. Some pursue additional specialized residency training in fields such as orthodontics, oral surgery, periodontics, or pediatric dentistry.

A Dentist's clinical practice includes:

  • Focuses on dental health, periodontal tissues, and oral cavity structures
  • Conducts patient examinations, obtains radiographic images, identifies oral pathology, develops treatment strategies, provides preventive counseling
  • Manages dental caries, periodontal disease, tooth deterioration, oral infections, and alignment issues
  • Provides prophylactic care, restorative procedures, prosthetic devices, endodontic therapy, extractions, and aesthetic treatments
  • Known as: general dentist, DDS, DMD, oral health provider

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the best way to search for a Dentist in Shelter Island who accepts my health insurance?
Navigate to the insurance filter located at the top of the search page and select your health plan. This will display only Dentists in Shelter Island who are in-network with your carrier. For additional confirmation, visit each doctor's profile or reach out to their office by phone.
Where can I find Dentists in Shelter Island who offer virtual appointments?
Select the "Virtual Visit" filter at the top of the search page to see Dentists providing telehealth services in Shelter Island. Check each doctor's profile for video visit options and online scheduling availability. You may also call their office to set up a remote consultation.
What's the easiest way to locate highly-rated Dentists in Shelter Island?
Use the "Ratings" filter at the top of the search page to filter results by the average star rating. Browse individual profiles to see patient reviews and ratings in detail. When comparing Dentists, look at both the average star rating and how many patients have submitted reviews.
Is it possible to schedule a same-day visit with a Dentist in Shelter Island?
Visit individual doctor profiles to see their current scheduling availability in Shelter Island. If you don't see same-day openings listed online, try calling their office—walk-in times may be available that don't appear on the website.
Which Dentists in Shelter Island have the shortest wait times?
Review the Ratings & Reviews card on each provider's profile to see their average wait time in Shelter Island. This helps you find a Dentist that doesn’t make their patients wait too long.
Can I schedule appointments with Dentists in Shelter Island without calling?
Search for Dentists who have "Book Online" or "Request Now" options on their profiles. Click these buttons to access online appointment scheduling. If a provider doesn't offer web-based booking, their phone number will be available for traditional scheduling.
How do I locate a Dentist in Shelter Island with evening or weekend hours?
Check the Locations card on each profile to view office hours for Dentists in Shelter Island. This helps you find providers with non-traditional availability. For the most accurate information about extended availability, call the office directly.
How do I leave feedback about my appointment with a Dentist in Shelter Island?
Go to your doctor's profile page and click the "Leave a Review" button or link. You can share your rating and write about your experience. Patient reviews like yours help others in the community choose the right Dentist.
How can I locate a Dentist in Shelter Island who is fluent in my preferred language?
Review the language information displayed on individual profiles for Dentists. If this information isn't available online, contact the office directly to ask about the doctor's language capabilities or whether interpreters are available.
How do I search for a Dentist in Shelter Island who works at a particular hospital or medical center?
Check the "Hospital Affiliation" and "Locations" sections on each provider's profile to see where Dentists practice. You can also enter a specific hospital or medical group name into the search tool to find Dentists who work there.

Ensuring Data Transparency and Trust: A Guide to Vitals Doctor Listings and Reviews

Our provider data is gathered directly from physicians and publicly available databases. Providers who verify their profiles gain the ability to update information, offering additional details about their specialties,education, treated conditions, performed procedures, and accepted insurances.

Reviews on Vitals are submitted by users only. Recognizing the valuable insights these reviews offer into a doctor's reputation, we maintain internal policies and protocols to ensure the quality and accuracy of all reviews. Importantly, providers cannot delete or alter reviews independently. Reviews can only be deleted or changed following an internal assessment by our customer service team.

Your feedback is highly valued and we encourage you to contact our support team should you encounter any issues.

Find Doctors

Copyright © 2026 Vitals Consumer Services, LLC. US Patent No. 8, 694, 441. All Rights Reserved.
As more fully set forth in this website's terms of use . (1) nothing contained on or offered by or through this website should be construed as medical advice and should not be relied upon for medical diagnosis or treatment. Vitals Consumer Services, LLC ("Vitals"). the provider of this website, does not recommend or endorse any particular healthcare provider whose information or ratings appear on this website; and (2) Vitals has granted you a limited license to access and use this website for your own noncommercial use. You are not permitted to copy, reproduce, distribute, transmit, mirror, frame, scrape, extract, wrap, create derivative works of, reverse engineer, decompile or disassemble any part or aspect of this website.