Dr. Anthony J Scillia, MD

Dr Scillia is such a nice dr. which is very hard to find these days. He is so humble and never talks down or at you. You actually get the feeling that he cares about his patients.

Dr. Scillia, Erica and Alex are an amazing team! Every encounter with this office has been met with a professional yet warm and caring attitude. When no other doctor I consulted for my pain was willing to help me, Dr. Scillia was. He is an amazing surgeon, has a wonderful bedside manner and takes the time to listen carefully to his patients. He is truly concerned and it is evident in the care he provides. I am a health care professional as well and recommend him without hesistation.

Dr. Anthony Scillia is the most amazing Ortho Surgeon that I have ever met and/or researched. Other Ortho Surgeons told me I would never be at 100% with the type of knee reconstruction I would have to have but I decided to go with Dr. Scillia and I have 100% of my knee function with no pain. He's a great person and explains everything in detail so that I understand and is also more than willing to take his time answering my questions. He's half man, half amazing! The best!

Dr. Scillia is an exceptional doctor! I had hip surgery and I back to playing golf in a month! I a so happy and impressed along with my friend who is just as pleased.

Dr Scillia was extremely helpful in diagnosing my rare injury (lisfranc displacement) after other doctors misread my x-rays. He has remained a helpful point of contact as I have progressed in my recovery, and I am happily back to 100%.

Dr. Scillia is a highly skilled doctor. He did my shoulder surgery and now I am completely back to playing tennis and and enjoying a full life. Not only is he an excellent physician, he really cares about his patients.

Dr Scillia is an amazing doctor who repaired my ACL. Not only did he comfort me in a difficult time knowing I was looking at a long recovery road - he did an amazing job repairing my knee. We talked about options of using my own tendons to repair and came up with the best option for my lifestyle. He's the only orthopedist I would recommend

After a few years, and several doctors who left me with no solution to my ankle pain, I was referred to Dr. Scillia. He was able to solve the problem on my first visit, and put me on a quick path to recovery. I highly recommend him!

Office cancelled the first appt. for my daughter the morning of. I called to reschedule and had to wait 2 weeks for another time that would work for us, meanwhile with my daughter in pain. Arrived for 3:45 appt on time. Xrays about an hour later. Many people in the waiting room said that a wait of well over an hour was typical for this doctor. At 5:55, I was told (only because I asked) there was still another patient waiting to see the doctor before us. Staff was sympathetic but powerless to help. We took our xrays and left without seeing him.

My 15 year son initially had a med epicondyle stress fracture surgery treated out of network with obscene Dr costs in NY. (HSS was in plan) A year later he needed another mri at HSS. That mri was inconclusive and more importantly as we found out -just wrong so he had another with dye under Dr Scillia's direction. Dr Scillia was recommended by elbow experts at Andrews Inst. in Alabama when I sent copies of all films there. I am so grateful. It was 1.5 years of uncertainty until Dr Scillia took control. Dr Scillia's complex surgery went smoothly. Hardware removal due to impingement, nerve transposition, ligament repair, and plasma treatment. His assistant Erica was available and patient with our questions. Also Dr Scillia's cost for the plasma treatment was 800 out of network in Morristown NJ vs HSS in NY 2000 out of network. That is almost criminal-what a racket. My son is now very happy and is on schedule with therapy. (Also Dr Scillia gave us a weekly protocol script after… surgery as opposed to NY Dr. giving us nothing but a script for 3 months of 3 days a week therapy) I remember the therapist back then said I have no instruction and need to call the DR. If the fancy NY Dr's don't want to care about the little people don't let us in the door.