Dr. Stephen Anthony Madry, MD

I was referred to Dr. Madry by my breast surgeon. I was scheduled for an appointment on 2/3/26 to discuss reconstruction after a level 2 oncoplastic excision. The surgeon would be removing a substantial amount of tissue, and reconstruction would be required to maintain symmetry. I had my first lumpectomy in 2024, after a pathology report that came back unable to rule out DCIS. My results had been forwarded to the Cleveland Clinic for a second opinion from the resident expert in ADH and DCIS. They were also unable to definitively rule out DCIS; the clinic states it errs on the side of ADH in these cases. So, I was referred to an oncologist for preventative chemo and had my lumpectomy. Unfortunately, I cannot take the oral chemo, as I had a gastric bypass and suffer from malabsorption. I continued the rotation of a DX mammogram and MRI every 6 months. In December of 2025, I had my follow-up MRI. The MRI showed two areas of concern. They were biopsied and determined to be… the same case as before, unable to rule out DCIS. At this point, the issue had returned, and the breast surgeon was treating it as DCIS, unless proven otherwise. This led to the level 2 oncoplastic excision. He stated he had discussed it with Dr. Madry, and I just needed to go for a consult. I showed up 2/3/26, by myself. I thought this would be a standard appointment to go over what would happen during and after the surgery. I was brought into the patient's room and seated in front of a very large window, without shades drawn, for about 15 minutes. Dr. Madry entered the room, holding a file with a piece of paper inside. He said, “I’m sorry you are going through this”. I was mid-response of “thank y..” when he interrupted and said, “ADH?? YOU DON’T HAVE CANCER. More like CONGRATULATIONS”. He lectured me for the next 4 minutes on how my insurance would never cover the reconstruction. He has dealt with insurance, and he knows. I tried to explain what was going on, and he just said, “Fine. I guess I can take a look. Put on the gown.” He walked out while I put on the gown (the window was still wide open). I sat on the exam table, waiting for him. He came in and said, “Stand up and open the gown”. I stood up, opened my gown, and he replied, “Well, you are DEFINITELY a good candidate for a lift, anyway.” I closed my gown, and he proceeded to tell me, again, that my insurance won’t cover any of it, but he will go ahead and submit it. I then asked him, “How long do you think it will take to hear from the insurance?” He replied, “Probably at least a week. I don’t know why you are in a hurry. YOU DON’T HAVE CANCER.” And walked out. At that point, I got dressed and hurried to my car, where I had a good cry. I then called my breast surgeon’s nurse and explained that I have decided not to have the procedure, and I would rather take my chances. They, of course, referred me to another surgeon (my breast surgeon is the absolute best and I trust him 100%). The new plastic surgeon is not only understanding, but also offers suggestions without lectures or humiliation. He acknowledges that my type 1 diabetes is a concern (I have had it for over 40 years) and he will make sure to keep a close watch. The kicker is that I received a bill with a copay of $247.49 for the (less than) 10 minutes that he spent lecturing and humiliating me. If you have had a good experience with this doctor, I will not try to convince you otherwise. However, I want people to know about my experience. To know that there are other options. Maybe he had a bad day, maybe he was overwhelmed, maybe it bothered him that the word CANCER wasn’t written in bold letters on my chart? I have no idea. I know that I don’t believe in comparative healthcare. Everyone deserves good care and respect. Especially when they are dealing with such an overwhelming situation.

Dr Madry did my reconstruction surgery, last summer, when I had breast cancer. He did an excellent job. So, when I decided that I needed to do something about my droopy eyelids, of course, he was the only one that I wanted to do it. I fell better about the way I look. I am very happy! He is the best!

I have had very large breasts all my life. When I was 12 I was popping out of a C cup. I have thought of having a reduction for years. Before my surgery I was popping out of a G cup, should have had an H but just couldn't bring myself to buy one. The pain in my neck and shoulders was getting worse every year. I finely said something to my PC and she is the one who told me the insurance might cover it. The process took only a few months and I was able to have my surgery before the end of the year. I'm now in a C cup and have lost 30 more lbs. I have no pain in my shoulders and my neck only bothers me once in a while. I am a mamm tech and have seen many breast surgeries that were not a good outcome. Dr. Madry was fantastic, he was up front with all the info. he gave me. Told me what could happen, it didn't. I plain on going back for another procedure in a few months. There was NO pain, I was back to work in 4 day and have felt like a new person ever since. It was one of the best things I… have ever done for myself. My only regret is that I waited so long!

Think twice before using this doctor, I had complications with my incision after reduction and lift for breast cancer surgery. The day of surgery I had heavy bleeding when I got home. Called his office twice with no call back, no direction on what to do. Had necrotic tissue, because incision fell apart. Doctor offered no options on how to fix, he lost interest couldn’t even keep him in room long enough to ask questions. Had an open wound for weeks until I switched plastic surgeons. He also does some patient blaming, said wouldn’t have happened if I wasn’t an ex-smoker. Haven’t smoked in 15 years, two other surgeons told me that was not true, and not based in any science. It’s deflection. He also has an infuriating habit of leaving exam room door open and walking out when patient is half dressed. I’m so sorry I ever let this doctor do my surgery. His failure to help me after complication delayed my radiation, and then this virus has delayed it even more. That’s not… the doctor fault but I could have been done before it started, if he would have given me options of a skin graft or wound vac. I understand completely that complications happen, that’s not what upsets me. His lack of response if you have a complication upsets me. If you have a complication, that’s when you need your doctor the most, my experience was this doctor won’t be there for you. His office staff is wonderful, but they don’t operate.’

I will be using Dr Madry again I recommend him to everyone .I am so happy I chose him to remove my basal cell cancer he is the best plastic surgeon ever ! I cannot thank him enough for the amazing work he did very impressed .

I’ve had multiple surgeries for breast reconstruction from having a bilateral mastectomy. I highly recommend him. He did exactly what I wanted an was informative, honest, friendly an overall just great. I’m thankful I have him as my PS.

Dr. Madry ran hot and cold with his moods. Mostly cold. All appointments with him brief and rushed feeling. Surgical skill set? Meh. Breasts uneven, cuts seem sloppy and mismatched. Pain, bruising, tightness, more so than other patients with different surgeons, (I've asked). Office wait either very long, or somewhat on time. Appointment/surgical availability also limited. Dr. seems bored by patients and would rather be somewhere else. Apparently he has a "fragile ego", sensitive to criticism. Try looking in my mirror Doc. I'll show you what feeling fragile and sensitive looks like.

Dr Madry was referred to me from My breast surgeon. They make an excellent team. He is highly skilled with an awesome nurse practitioner, Claire. He has a great sense of humor. His results are great! Definitely recommended.

I saw Dr Madry, and to be honest I was shocked w anything except perfect. Dr Madry makes sure he is able to perform as he tells you exactly what you are going to have done. Often, people who expect much more than practical results are the ones who leave bad reviews.... not to sound snobby but if you’re not built like a Barbie you will not look like a Barbie after either! He only has what you give him to work his magic. He is not only a very kind man but he definitely does not do this for the pay alone like most plastic surgeons, especially directly near him geographically. If you are big boned to begin with, there is nothing to change that. Maybe start working on accepting yourself or get psychological help instead of tearing down a good surgeon. But then again, plastics will always be plastics. Patients always build this fake look they don’t realize until after the procedure. MD’s really should require a psych evaluation prior to their appointment. Sad, Dr Madry is amazing.

Butchered my mother in laws reconstructive surgery after breast cancer! And a jerk. Avoid!