Dr. Randi Michelle Rothstein, MD

She was the worst doctor I have ever had of my 3 labors/deliveries. I can't stress enough how cruel the entire experience was as she insisted on rushing my labor along stating "she didn't have time for this," as soon as I got to the hospital and hurting me and my baby to the point of forcing dilation so roughly by hand that she caused my baby to flip, then stating I almost needed a c-section as if it was my fault. She caused my baby come out with a huge goose egg on her head/subdermal hematoma as a result of her rushing the process and ramming her hand into our baby's head. This is not a good doctor, she's just out to make a quick buck at the expense of you and your baby's health. MOMS BEWARE AND SPARE YOUR BABY THE AGONY OF BEING BORN BY HER!

I have been going to Dr. Rothstein for at least 15 years. She is kind, very compassionate, thorough and always supportive. She is also a brilliant doctor. When I go to her yearly, I feel like the office is like family. Thank you for all you do.

Dr. Rothstein is the best doctor. Caring, professional yet so down to earth. She’s blunt and tells it like it is which is what I love about her. I have been seeing her for 20 years.

Dr Rothstein is very profressional, caring and smart. I have been a patient for many years. She always calls with results in a very timely manner. She has a very pleasant manner. The only negative is the long wait- minimum one hour.

After consulting with other OBs after my delivery I came to realize that my crash csection was more than likely caused by a rushed physician at the end of her shift in the hospital looking to bank on my baby. She was an excellent surgeon (nicknamed “Scissorhands”) most likely due to her unnecessary experience. I love the practice where she works however during my next pregnancy I will opt to deliver without the practice if she is the physician on call. If you have to schedule a csection I would suggest her, otherwise she is not for everyone.

In my opinion Dr. Rothstein should not be allowed to deliver babies. I personally witnessed the consequences of her horrible delivery of an otherwise healthy baby. The baby suffered long term consequences. When I discussed the case with a top OBGYN at Mount Sinai, he said that the technique used by Dr. Rothstein was horrible and not in use for already over 30 years. I wouldn't recommend Dr. Rothstein to anyone.

Dr Rothstein is quite knowledgeable in helping me find the problem that many other Gynecologist couldn't find, she is more compassionate towards very elderly women such as myself and explained to my son the proper care for using the medication for me. Its only 24 hours since my visit with Dr Rothstein I feel 90% better and I slept with minor discomfort which is a great improvement from before. I can only say thank you Dr Rothstein your my savior and I'm now your patient for ever.

Honestly been with this office 16 years... Everything is wonderful until there is a problem.. Dr. Rothstein has no bedside manner.. I have endimitriosis..Which her way of solving the problem was putting me on birth control Seasonique. Which would stop the bleeding for 3 months..basically the doctors don't perform any blood work or other tests to get to the root of the problem.. Checking for adrenal glad levels or checking progesterone levels. They are pill pushers nothing is natural..When you ask a question she looks at you like are you for real? I guess its time to change Doctor and oh during the visit she is very rough. Talk about no bedside manner. God forbid you have an emergency they call back after their shift is over at 10:30PM? I had Dr Herzog that while performing my pap he asked me if iI shaved or wax? I was mortified... he hands me a business card trying to promote his wife's laser hair removal business? Totally turned off with the whole office. Make sure you get a snack… and good book cause you will be in the office for at least 2 hours. Another turn off... In this office your just a number! The whole medical system is messed up.. You just have to go where your feel comfortable.

Fantastic doctor. Very thorough and smart - also wonderful bedside manner.

I don't understand how this woman has good reviews. I waited 1 1/2 hours to see her. Went into the smallest exam room I have seen in my 51 years, which I assume they made extra small so that they can make many exam rooms to pack all the women. When she was finally examining me, she asked me if I had life insurance. I froze; so she asked me again. I lost my sister from breast cancer 2 years prior to that. I thought she saw something as she was examining me. I finally said no I didn't and is there something wrong? She went on to tell me about what they had to offer in her office. I wanted to get up and beat the crap out of this heartless, cold non human and I'm not a violent person. At that point I think I was numb. She took e to her office trying to sell me more of whatever she was selling, in a pseudo concerned voice almost yelling. Telling me that she would call me with my results of my pap smear and would then ask me if I was interested. I left in shock and started to cry in car.… She never called with my pap smear results and I'm glad she didn't. Maybe she treats pregnant women different, but I'd rather be seen by Vet than her. Woman to woman...Shame on her!!!