Mona Deora Duncan, MD

Very caring.

Extremely good, very complete and informative

Dr. Duncan is a remarkably good physician. She thoroughly reviewed the surgery that had been performed and looked at my scar. I relayed to her how pleased I was with the behavior of the entire Ambulatory Surgery staff on the day of my surgery. She discussed with me at length the options for follow-up treatment, and we discussed the benefits of undertaking radiation therapy and possibly also oral (anti-estrogenic) chemotherapy. She was thorough and detailed in her explanations and listened attentively and with genuine care to my questions and concerns. She is a very impressive physician and an asset to the Geisinger system!

Dr. Duncan has been amazing throughout the entire breast cancer journey. Always willing to listen and answer all my questions.

I met with Dr. Duncan following an abnormal mammogram. She knew that I was interested in discussing the possibility of prophylactic mastectomy and reconstruction. However, she spoke about the "process" only in terms of implants. When I asked her about autologous approaches (e.g., DIEP flap), she generally dismissed it and told me that she didn't think I was a candidate. If I had not done my own research and had only followed her lead, I would have taken a very different course of action -- one that I am very, very grateful that I took. I am writing this review because it concerns me that other women in similar situations may not understand that full disclosure of options may not be forthcoming. It is okay if a given surgeon does not perform a procedure or does not think it's a great one, but I believe that it is unethical to not inform women of all of their options.

Dr. Duncan exudes confidence, is professional yet kind and relieves your worries. She operated on me 2 days ago and it all went the way she explained it. I couldn't be more pleased.

Dr. Mona Duncan M.D. was wonderful, she had preformed a lumpectomy and she was very professional and very comforting. She was wonderful. Thank you Dr. Duncan and all your staff for your great work!!!!

After a terrible experience with an ER doctor who never consulted with a surgeon and having to return to the ER the following a.m., Dr. Duncan was consulted by the ER doc on duty and she determined I needed my gall bladder removed. I was so relieved to know someone finally was helping me. I cannot thank her enough.

During my office visit, Dr Mona Duncan seemed very distracted and almost uninterested as I was describing my medical history and the reason for my visit. In retrospect I probably should have asked her if she was okay to draw attention to her demeanor. Her recommendation to do nothing for 6 months because the likely that this condition was a problem was small, was ridiculous to me. According to Dr Duncan, the lump is scar tissue and not something to be concerned about because there is an extremely small chance that it is something else. This recommendation was unacceptable to me for two reasons (1) a large mass of scar tissue forming 14 years after surgery concerns me and (2) why on earth would I want to wait 6 months if I could find out now.It was only after I continually and repeatedly asked for more information on how to make a definitive diagnosis, did Dr Duncan finally make a suggestion. I left the office with the intent to seek a second opinion from a doctor who would listen… while I described my medical history, perform a thorough examination and willingly provide a way to make a definitive diagnosis. When I received a copy of Dr Duncans notes to bring to my second opinion consultation, I was extremely disappointed although unfortunately not surprised to see that her notes began with inaccurately reporting important medical history information. Dr Duncans notes incorrectly referenced the type and outcome of a previous surgery I had. In fact, Dr Duncans notes specifically state I did not have a biopsy for a palpable lump. This is untrue. Apparently, Dr Duncan was not listening to the details I was conveying to her during my visit, nor did she bother to go over the medical history information provided in my new patient chart. Prior to my visit, I was directed to a website to download and complete medical forms which also included information on my previous surgical biopsy. Also, Dr Duncans notes state she did not feel the swollen lymph node in my neck which she would not have during her cursory and distracted examination. I mentioned the lymph node to Dr Duncan because during an examination by my asthma specialist, that doctor brought the lump to my attention and suggested I see a specialist (since that was not her area of medicine). I was not satisfied with the medical treatment I received during my visit with Dr Mona Duncan at the Columbia office. Dr Duncans recommendation for me to wait for 6 months was unacceptable to me. A good doctor (even an average doctor) would provide me with the options on how to make a definitive diagnosis upfront without me having to ask. Arriving at the correct diagnosis within the shortest amount of time should be a given when a patient is in their office for a consultation.